National Forum

Longford GAA thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To LongfordSham:  "Bottom 2 i believe are to be relegated from the playoff, which would be bloody ridiculous and a needless extra portion of games. League phase 1, League phase 2, Relegation round robin league, followed by a league phase Intermediate championship."
Division 2 has same number of teams as last year. Last year each team played 11 rounds of games, and if you were in relegation you played 1 more, so 12 games total that season. That compares to 8 rounds of games this year across two phases, and 2 more games in a 3-team relegation playoff, so 11 games total this year if you are in relegation.

The number of games isn't the issue. The complexity is the issue IMO. Why not just play one division and let the two Killoe's play each other - the world won't end. Then have table position at the bottom decide who goes down. I don't see the point of relegation playoffs unless teams end up on same points. Then again I don't see the point of the Top 2 or Top 4 cups either. A league should finish with top team as champions and bottom team(s) relegated, nice and simple. More cups is unnecessary.

LongfordgaaAbú (Longford) - Posts: 679 - 17/06/2026 12:14:51    2680293

Link

Replying To LongfordgaaAbú:  "Division 2 has same number of teams as last year. Last year each team played 11 rounds of games, and if you were in relegation you played 1 more, so 12 games total that season. That compares to 8 rounds of games this year across two phases, and 2 more games in a 3-team relegation playoff, so 11 games total this year if you are in relegation.

The number of games isn't the issue. The complexity is the issue IMO. Why not just play one division and let the two Killoe's play each other - the world won't end. Then have table position at the bottom decide who goes down. I don't see the point of relegation playoffs unless teams end up on same points. Then again I don't see the point of the Top 2 or Top 4 cups either. A league should finish with top team as champions and bottom team(s) relegated, nice and simple. More cups is unnecessary."
100% agree with you on the league finishing with the top team as winning promotion and bottom team relegated.
On the two Killoes playing each other, doesn't the weaker of the Div 2 Killoe team still pull a few players from the stronger of the Div 2 Killoe team? I know last year they had players playing Div 2 and Div 3.

Frank74 (Longford) - Posts: 221 - 17/06/2026 13:52:18    2680320

Link