National Forum

Roscommon GAA thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Anyone thinking of going to the match in Mulligar via Longford should give themselves extra time as the road between Longford and Mullingar is closed off due to an accident and detours are in place.

letsgetgoing (Roscommon) - Posts: 702 - 23/03/2025 09:43:52    2597909

Link

Replying To FullOfPorter:  "Whatever the personel, we need to see more intensity and fight.

I know Davy's comments were off the wall but in one way at least he has some human passion, we are so used to robotic player and manager interviews in the GAA. 'Yea sure we just were second best today, sure we'll regroup and go again the next day, sure we just didn't get over the line...' bla blah waffle waffle yawn, might as well let AI do them."
And every third word is "look" or "lookit".
Anyway let's hope for a good performance and a win so as if things go for us elsewhere we'll be promoted.

Seanfanbocht (Roscommon) - Posts: 2171 - 23/03/2025 11:14:55    2597922

Link

Replying To Seanfanbocht:  "And every third word is "look" or "lookit".
Anyway let's hope for a good performance and a win so as if things go for us elsewhere we'll be promoted."
Ha, that's it exactly, forgot the lookit! 'Sure lookit another day you get those decisions'

Yes, that's the main thing, need a good reaction now. As long as Roscommon do their own job, hopefully the other results go our way. Safe travelling to all.

FullOfPorter (Roscommon) - Posts: 27 - 23/03/2025 11:44:51    2597925

Link

That was rather depressing stuff. Burke was right last week although he shouldn't be stating it publicly. The lethargic shooting and complancy second half should have cost us but luckily other results went our way. The subs made us worse if anything. I get the feeling it's not going to get any better either.

superos (Roscommon) - Posts: 49 - 23/03/2025 15:36:09    2597972

Link

Replying To superos:  "That was rather depressing stuff. Burke was right last week although he shouldn't be stating it publicly. The lethargic shooting and complancy second half should have cost us but luckily other results went our way. The subs made us worse if anything. I get the feeling it's not going to get any better either."
Pretty much spot on assessment there. Subs were awful. Don't like mentioning names but I've seen nothing from Cox or Killoran to suggest they are anywhere near intercounty level. Brian Stack will be needed back very soon to shore up the defence. Our decision making has been very poor also. Taking on pot shots when the chance I really not on. Then going for goals instead of taking our points. I have to say I've very little confidence in the management team. Lessons don't appear to have been learnt and it's very worrying going into the championship. To think we got promotion back to Div 1 yet it feels like a defeat today and relegation after that performance. 12 points up and then to be completely outscored by a poor team and lucky to get a draw in the end.

ComainRos (Roscommon) - Posts: 146 - 23/03/2025 15:53:49    2597982

Link

Talk about getting the rub of green. A totally diaseter up 8pts at half time and then collapse in the second half. Missing simple frees and defenders yards of there man.Westmeath also had about 5 goals chances. It's very concerning whats happening.

hontherossie (Roscommon) - Posts: 121 - 23/03/2025 16:10:44    2597991

Link

Replying To ComainRos:  "Pretty much spot on assessment there. Subs were awful. Don't like mentioning names but I've seen nothing from Cox or Killoran to suggest they are anywhere near intercounty level. Brian Stack will be needed back very soon to shore up the defence. Our decision making has been very poor also. Taking on pot shots when the chance I really not on. Then going for goals instead of taking our points. I have to say I've very little confidence in the management team. Lessons don't appear to have been learnt and it's very worrying going into the championship. To think we got promotion back to Div 1 yet it feels like a defeat today and relegation after that performance. 12 points up and then to be completely outscored by a poor team and lucky to get a draw in the end."
A poor team? Some attitude to have. We lost three matches by a point in division 2, competed well against everyone except Monaghan, clearly this superiority complex fed in to your players too who went for goals constantly as if ye were easily going to win. Not many so called poor teams in div 1 next January, maybe you will learn some humility after a quick return to div 2

Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 2086 - 23/03/2025 16:20:39    2597993

Link

Promoted and was it ever really in doubt? Seriously though the was a division 2 campaign ultra competitive between a group of wildly inconsistent teams with little between any of them.

In the end 9 points enough for promotion and teams behind us only good enough for 8. Next years Div 2 will harder to get promotion so good we got up regardless of making it harder than it should be.

Nice to get a run out in Croke Park next week with the opportunity to win silverware but I'm thinking attention will already be turned to London to be sure we don't slip up on that banana skin

The_analyser (Roscommon) - Posts: 3983 - 23/03/2025 16:32:57    2597998

Link

Westmeath looked a poor team in the 1st half when we went 12 up, and I said at halftime it was a bit of a concern that they scored 4 in a row before halftime.
Complacent? Yes, absolutely, couldn't see anything other than a comfortable win in the 2nd half.
Westmeath showed why they are no bad team in the 2nd half, but to call it anything other than an abject collapse from us is disingenuous.
Humility? We will get our fill of it next year, or even over the championship this year, without major improvements- top of the list being able to perform at a sustained level through full games.
We're a long way from notions this evening, but we have time. How we use it will be telling.

Substandard (Roscommon) - Posts: 9 - 23/03/2025 16:44:08    2598007

Link

Replying To Claretandblue:  "A poor team? Some attitude to have. We lost three matches by a point in division 2, competed well against everyone except Monaghan, clearly this superiority complex fed in to your players too who went for goals constantly as if ye were easily going to win. Not many so called poor teams in div 1 next January, maybe you will learn some humility after a quick return to div 2"
No Roscommon person should be on here having a go at Westmeath who battled bravely for the draw today and who have been the unlucky team of Division 2. But from a Roscommon point of view, that second half collapse was shocking. We're promoted by luck of results elsewhere and it's hard to say we deserved it. If Roscommon continue like this, it'll be a short Summer for us and back then to Division 2 as you say. The frustrating thing is that Roscommon have talent all over the pitch, are capable of playing great football and yet we lose at home to Cavan, are hammered by a poor Meath and fall away as we did today. I think Roscommon have huge issues with the Management who are not nearly at the level required for a team with ambitions for the top. No disrespect to the Lake county, but Roscommon were running around like headless chickens near the end today( poor decision making, rushed shooting) and the team substitutions from the line definitely didn't help. It's the sourest promotion I've ever known.

endgame (Roscommon) - Posts: 2345 - 23/03/2025 16:55:36    2598009

Link

Replying To Claretandblue:  "A poor team? Some attitude to have. We lost three matches by a point in division 2, competed well against everyone except Monaghan, clearly this superiority complex fed in to your players too who went for goals constantly as if ye were easily going to win. Not many so called poor teams in div 1 next January, maybe you will learn some humility after a quick return to div 2"
What do you mean attitude? That's the reality for you. We were far more competitive in Div1 last year than ye were in Div 2 this year and yet we were a poor Div 1 team. it's no coincidence either when you were relegated with a couple of rounds to spare. Some people are so easily offended by facts been pointed out. Just for the record Roscommon are no great shakes this season either. It was a poor standard in Div 2 all round in my opinion. Unlike last year there'll be no teams from Div 2 threatening in the race for Sam Maguire this summer unfortunately.

ComainRos (Roscommon) - Posts: 146 - 23/03/2025 16:58:44    2598010

Link

Replying To ComainRos:  "Pretty much spot on assessment there. Subs were awful. Don't like mentioning names but I've seen nothing from Cox or Killoran to suggest they are anywhere near intercounty level. Brian Stack will be needed back very soon to shore up the defence. Our decision making has been very poor also. Taking on pot shots when the chance I really not on. Then going for goals instead of taking our points. I have to say I've very little confidence in the management team. Lessons don't appear to have been learnt and it's very worrying going into the championship. To think we got promotion back to Div 1 yet it feels like a defeat today and relegation after that performance. 12 points up and then to be completely outscored by a poor team and lucky to get a draw in the end."
You don't like to mention names, but you still did !!!

eoinog (Sligo) - Posts: 2050 - 23/03/2025 17:05:05    2598014

Link

Replying To ComainRos:  "What do you mean attitude? That's the reality for you. We were far more competitive in Div1 last year than ye were in Div 2 this year and yet we were a poor Div 1 team. it's no coincidence either when you were relegated with a couple of rounds to spare. Some people are so easily offended by facts been pointed out. Just for the record Roscommon are no great shakes this season either. It was a poor standard in Div 2 all round in my opinion. Unlike last year there'll be no teams from Div 2 threatening in the race for Sam Maguire this summer unfortunately."
Another ill informed poster from Ros. We drew with the team that got promotion and lost three matches by a point. Yet we weren't competitive in division 2? Come back on here when ye have a match won in championship in Croker. The Jigger and Gay Sheerin were involved last time. Imagine how ye would fare in a province where one win suffices to make last 12

Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 2086 - 23/03/2025 17:55:47    2598039

Link

Never have I left a game where we get promoted and reach a final but feel dejected. Really poor from the end of the 1st half and through the second half. Skills execution way off. Obviously the Cavan result was not a kick up the arse. The worrying thing is when Westmeath started narrowing the gap we didn't seem to have any composed heads from our senior players steadying the ship like you would see a Paul Conroy or Aidan O'Shea do. Headless chickens everywhere. It looks like as much of a mental problem as anything else. Very fortunate not to lose and that all other results went our way. We don't look like we play like a cohesive team, not sure what that is down to? The new rules might explain some of it but that felt like the Clare game a few years ago. For all the talk of our forwards, we are in fifth place when it comes to points scored in Division 2.

They need to draw a line under that league campaign now and get an improved perfomance in against Monaghan. We need more of the good fielding we showed for the first 50 or so minutes. The few times long kick passes were played on the counter they worked nicely. What is our defensive strategy? Is it some sort of half zonal half man marking? Because it looks like a number of players either don't know who they are supposed to be tracking or they are just falling asleep. Some players like Hand, Neary and Fallon give everything for the 50 50 ball but you need all players with that attitude.

FullOfPorter (Roscommon) - Posts: 27 - 23/03/2025 18:14:48    2598052

Link

I don't know what to say about our league campaign. It's good to get promotion but my god defensively we are like a division 3 team. Every game this year teams are running through us and I can't understand how we don't lay a hand on the opposition at all. What will the top forwards like the Galway lads do to us if we play like that.

dave1988 (Roscommon) - Posts: 1216 - 23/03/2025 18:27:15    2598060

Link

Over the last few years I've often thought we never got a break luck was never on our side . Well we got it in spades in this league campaign but it wasn't deserved so poor again today in what was the weakest division 2 in a long time no disrespect to any team - anyway it is what it is but It's very hard to see how they can flick
A switch for championship-
league final total nonsense next week if we were to win it will only paper over cracks and I hope the players are rightly tuned in for London game -
honestly I'm at a loss bad enough having to depend on favours from teams to get promoted but failing to win our own game today there are no words !

rossy15 (Roscommon) - Posts: 638 - 23/03/2025 18:40:38    2598066

Link

Replying To Claretandblue:  "Another ill informed poster from Ros. We drew with the team that got promotion and lost three matches by a point. Yet we weren't competitive in division 2? Come back on here when ye have a match won in championship in Croker. The Jigger and Gay Sheerin were involved last time. Imagine how ye would fare in a province where one win suffices to make last 12"
Leave it out. Roscommon have big problems and every Roscommon supporter knows that. If we keep playing like in the Cavan match or like in the second half today, we have no business being in Division 1. I do think Roscommon have a lot of good footballers but it's not being put together on the pitch in a coordinated way at all. I absolutely blame Davy and so do most Roscommon supporters I know but maybe we're not just good enough as a team whoever's in charge. As another poster said, the second half had the feel of our late collapse against Clare in Croke Park a few years back. Roscommon have some very experienced players but there was no head nor tail to their play in the latter stages of the match today. No cool heads anywhere. It's really disappointing.

endgame (Roscommon) - Posts: 2345 - 23/03/2025 18:42:08    2598067

Link

Replying To Claretandblue:  "Another ill informed poster from Ros. We drew with the team that got promotion and lost three matches by a point. Yet we weren't competitive in division 2? Come back on here when ye have a match won in championship in Croker. The Jigger and Gay Sheerin were involved last time. Imagine how ye would fare in a province where one win suffices to make last 12"
Ye have been very unlucky this year. And if ye had full strength team I think ye would have been fighting for promotion today. I don't know your route through the Leinster championship but if ye can avoid the dubs ye have the beating of Kildare and Meath for sure. If I was a westmeath supporter I'd be very proud of them lads with change in manager and so many players not available this year. Ye had great fitness and hunger today and that game could have went either way. Best of luck in the championship

dave1988 (Roscommon) - Posts: 1216 - 23/03/2025 18:44:34    2598070

Link

Game of two halves if there ever was one with the wind not really being a major factor. Well done to the team and management on getting promotion. However while it might be one thing being inconsistent between matches, inconconsistancy in the same match is at another level. I thought the team played extremely well for the first 30 minutes and it appeared to go down hill from there.
Westmeath however deserve great credit for their comeback.
Maybe someone might clarify two things for me:
× Did Enda Smith score a goal which was not given?
× Was the time up before the Westmeath goalkeeper kicked out the ball for the final play where Westmeath scored a 2 pointer.
The above did impact on our promotion hopes, but it could well have done.

letsgetgoing (Roscommon) - Posts: 702 - 23/03/2025 19:06:33    2598083

Link

Like everyone else, I really don't know how to feel about that result! Cruising after 25mins, playing fast attacking football to that shambles of a 2nd half! And only for a couple of poorly executed final passes, Westmeath would have been in for at least 3 more goals. I know we missed a few too, Enda and Diarmuid guilty of missing huge chances, but the way teams are cutting us open is a huge worry. Teams getting in down the centre of our defence without a glove laid on them is worrying going forward and needs to be addressed. I have held off criticising Davy and his coaches before now but today his changes in the 2nd half definitely weakened us, no question. Chances for points when we were under pressure missed, not good enough at this level. We still don't have a settled team. For me, I thought Ruarai Fallon was our best player. Keith Doyle very good in first half.
Anyway, promotion was the aim at the start, promotion is our reward. Whether we win a final or not, I wouldn't be too worried. Maybe get more minutes into a few lads, the likes of Ronan Daly, Cathal Heneghan would be more benefit and be prepared for the following Saturday in Ruislip

D.Hyde (Roscommon) - Posts: 259 - 23/03/2025 19:08:15    2598084

Link