National Forum

Experimental Railway Cup

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Watching match referee brough ball up 50 meters the ulster player bumped into John Maher he gave it for Maher not moving away it's like rugby now that is definitely one rule that can't come in image a club match they be uproar , they way Marty snd Eamon are cometary u woukd think these new rules are best thing ever it's a glorified practice match with nothing a stake wait until league starts

Kickitout (Galway) - Posts: 953 - 19/10/2024 19:47:04    2575865

Link

Has anyone told the Ulster fellas they're still allowed to tackle the opposition?

Ulsterman (Antrim) - Posts: 9785 - 19/10/2024 20:09:51    2575868

Link

Replying To BarneyGrant:  "Paddy Small has retained his "no passing to anyone even John" rule :-)

As someone who was hostile I have to say it was not a bad spectacle. Would need to have a bit of an edge to really assess but an prepared to admit that I was too harsh prematurely."
It's good stuff, a massive improvement. Why is Marty Morrissey whinging so much about handpassing? There's way more use of the boot in this game, and anyway no one minds handpassing when it's generally heading vertically as opposed to laterally.

Pope_Benedict (Galway) - Posts: 3875 - 19/10/2024 20:12:40    2575869

Link

I don't like the rule where a player can call a mark but play on, take a shot, but if the shot is saved it goes back to the original mark and he gets a free shot again. If you've played on and got a shot away that should be advantage over.

ballydalane (Kilkenny) - Posts: 1256 - 19/10/2024 20:49:06    2575872

Link

Well now. Its not like me to admit i was wrong, but that was brilliant stuff.

BarneyGrant (Dublin) - Posts: 3120 - 19/10/2024 20:58:16    2575873

Link

Exciting finish. The last minute and a half was very dramatic. I like the dynamic of teams having to "work" a 2 pointer near the end if they're 2 down.

ballydalane (Kilkenny) - Posts: 1256 - 19/10/2024 21:01:42    2575874

Link

Replying To ballydalane:  "I don't like the rule where a player can call a mark but play on, take a shot, but if the shot is saved it goes back to the original mark and he gets a free shot again. If you've played on and got a shot away that should be advantage over."
That's the one rule I don't like but most of the rest worked well but it was only a practice match with no real bite… Handing the ball back is real juvenile stuff… why not just place it on the ground…? It would make more sense… overall a great final..!

ForeverBlue2 (Cavan) - Posts: 3029 - 19/10/2024 21:18:55    2575877

Link

Replying To ballydalane:  "Exciting finish. The last minute and a half was very dramatic. I like the dynamic of teams having to "work" a 2 pointer near the end if they're 2 down."
Enjoyable but I tell ya.. Mayo are In trouble as they'll have so many lads trying the 2 pointers and they'll all drop short..
Majority of their scorers are close in tap overs...
Boland and Touhy had shocking late efforts there tonight..
Thankfully Johnny Heaney nailed his two

Belclare7 (Galway) - Posts: 115 - 19/10/2024 21:28:36    2575878

Link

Very enjoyable game and gives the cttee something to work on.
I doubt if they expected the keeper to be sp prominent up the field but most keepers are not as fit as Morgan.
The arc will be impossible to monitor.
The Throw in favours the team whose player is contesting the throw in and facing the sideline where his team mate is.
That's for starters

eoinog (Sligo) - Posts: 1958 - 19/10/2024 21:37:06    2575881

Link

Replying To legendzxix:  "I think the 40m arc is sensible from outside the 20m line. I wouldn't be splitting hairs over that one."
OK, but where is the logic in stopping the arc at the 20 metre line?
There must be some reason for it.

Aibrean (Kerry) - Posts: 304 - 19/10/2024 21:47:26    2575884

Link

New or old rules I'll never warm to penalty shootout to decide a GAA match. Our lads poor at penalties doesn't help my feelings on it either.

The_analyser (Roscommon) - Posts: 3909 - 19/10/2024 21:51:53    2575885

Link

Replying To Belclare7:  "Enjoyable but I tell ya.. Mayo are In trouble as they'll have so many lads trying the 2 pointers and they'll all drop short..
Majority of their scorers are close in tap overs...
Boland and Touhy had shocking late efforts there tonight..
Thankfully Johnny Heaney nailed his two"
It can be trying listening to a high infants adjudicators but let us be charitable they on only parrot what they hear at home.What we watched for 2 nights will have very little comparison to what will result after congress decides changes and competitive games.Wait and see what is the final outcome is before making assumptions based on maybe's.

backtooldwall (Galway) - Posts: 138 - 19/10/2024 21:59:11    2575886

Link

Replying To BarneyGrant:  "Well now. Its not like me to admit i was wrong, but that was brilliant stuff."
I'm shocked!!!!
Just home from Croke Park.
Was enjoyable apart from the hash of the penalties.

Seanfanbocht (Roscommon) - Posts: 1956 - 19/10/2024 23:16:21    2575892

Link

Replying To ForeverBlue2:  "That's the one rule I don't like but most of the rest worked well but it was only a practice match with no real bite… Handing the ball back is real juvenile stuff… why not just place it on the ground…? It would make more sense… overall a great final..!"
I needed to read your post 3 times. Can't believe you said something positive.

Saynothing (Tyrone) - Posts: 2150 - 19/10/2024 23:18:42    2575893

Link

Replying To ballydalane:  "Exciting finish. The last minute and a half was very dramatic. I like the dynamic of teams having to "work" a 2 pointer near the end if they're 2 down."
Exciting when you use the stop clock. Though the time keeping worked well.

Saynothing (Tyrone) - Posts: 2150 - 19/10/2024 23:22:02    2575894

Link

As per my most recent post on Galway thread I had high hopes for the new rules. I am a long term season ticket holder and have been around this forum from the start but all I can say is that if this format goes ahead I have watched and attended my last game. It is absolute tripe . Football was really really bad in recent seasons but this has made it 10 times worse. It is dire altogether.

giveitlong (Galway) - Posts: 1258 - 20/10/2024 07:47:18    2575905

Link

Thoroughly enjoyed all of the games, there could be something in this. Ulster on top again - a great year for the province.

sam2024 (Armagh) - Posts: 38 - 20/10/2024 08:26:55    2575907

Link

Replying To eoinog:  "Very enjoyable game and gives the cttee something to work on.
I doubt if they expected the keeper to be sp prominent up the field but most keepers are not as fit as Morgan.
The arc will be impossible to monitor.
The Throw in favours the team whose player is contesting the throw in and facing the sideline where his team mate is.
That's for starters"
Not sure the throw in is an issue as you say but if so first half, second half can be alternated if it isn't already.

sligo joe (Dublin) - Posts: 795 - 20/10/2024 08:38:42    2575908

Link

Replying To backtooldwall:  "It can be trying listening to a high infants adjudicators but let us be charitable they on only parrot what they hear at home.What we watched for 2 nights will have very little comparison to what will result after congress decides changes and competitive games.Wait and see what is the final outcome is before making assumptions based on maybe's."
Don't listen like a good lad...
" trying" I'd say you are some fun

Belclare7 (Galway) - Posts: 115 - 20/10/2024 08:50:29    2575911

Link

Replying To Seanfanbocht:  "I'm shocked!!!!
Just home from Croke Park.
Was enjoyable apart from the hash of the penalties."
I won't be making a habit of it, the apologising I mean.

Penalties were comicically bad. Getting rid of them would be a definite "advancement."

BarneyGrant (Dublin) - Posts: 3120 - 20/10/2024 08:52:53    2575912

Link