Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

National Forum

Some Updates On The Football Review

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post

Replying To Fionn:  "Fully agree with you on this."
I'm not convinced by the 2 point free period. Kicking a 2 pointer from play is a whole different skill. For a lot of players the 2 point free is not quite a gimme but close. If a really good penetrative team attack ends with a defence foul on the 20m line, just a one pointer?

sligo joe (Dublin) - Posts: 1195 - 11/11/2026 14:34:40    2700086

Link

Replying To Fionn:  "I would bring the arc out to 45m"
The whole point of 40m is that its a skill but is still attainable for a lot of players at the top level. If each team only has one or two kickers who can score from the 2 point line the defense can stay far more compact than if they have 5 or 6 capable. Plus a 45m arc would hit the sidelines on some pitches

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 56 - 11/11/2026 14:47:44    2700088

Link

Replying To otgarom:  "The whole point of 40m is that its a skill but is still attainable for a lot of players at the top level. If each team only has one or two kickers who can score from the 2 point line the defense can stay far more compact than if they have 5 or 6 capable. Plus a 45m arc would hit the sidelines on some pitches"
As for hitting the sidelines on some pitches….
Defo worth 2 points then… lol

Sure some u15's are hitting 2 pointers, so it is not just top level players who can do it.
Move the arc out I say…! ;o)

Fionn (Dublin) - Posts: 5360 - 11/11/2026 16:27:49    2700104

Link

Replying To sligo joe:  "I'm not convinced by the 2 point free period. Kicking a 2 pointer from play is a whole different skill. For a lot of players the 2 point free is not quite a gimme but close. If a really good penetrative team attack ends with a defence foul on the 20m line, just a one pointer?"
The problem with a free not being a two pointer at all, is it incentivises fouling a player about to kick a two pointer. If my team is two ahead at the end of a match and the ball is worked to their best forward to kick a two point effort, then it's a no-brainer to foul him every time.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 3185 - 11/11/2026 17:19:07    2700112

Link

Replying To Fionn:  "As for hitting the sidelines on some pitches….
Defo worth 2 points then… lol

Sure some u15's are hitting 2 pointers, so it is not just top level players who can do it.
Move the arc out I say…! ;o)"
Move the arc out and thereby create a more defensive game?

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 56 - 11/11/2026 18:07:06    2700117

Link

Replying To sligo joe:  "I'm not convinced by the 2 point free period. Kicking a 2 pointer from play is a whole different skill. For a lot of players the 2 point free is not quite a gimme but close. If a really good penetrative team attack ends with a defence foul on the 20m line, just a one pointer?"
Imagine David Clifford, Ryan O'Donoghue, Sam Mulroy, Jack Carney, Jack McCarron, Oisín O'Neill, etc. Are lining up a two pointer or have got a step on their man outside the arc, what is their man going to do? Obviously foul them if the free will only be worth one, with players like that the result is nearly guaranteed to be a net positive for the defending team over the course of a game/season.

Also, 2 points up in the last minute of a game, a team is outside the arc, trying to work a two pointer, just foul them and go man to man for the free, trying to retain and get controlled possesion from a free kick is far harder and more time consuming than doing so from open play.

Getting two points for a free might be seen as too much of a punishment but it's very much q nessecery evil.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 56 - 11/11/2026 19:05:51    2700123

Link

Replying To WanPintWin:  "The problem with a free not being a two pointer at all, is it incentivises fouling a player about to kick a two pointer. If my team is two ahead at the end of a match and the ball is worked to their best forward to kick a two point effort, then it's a no-brainer to foul him every time."
Exactly!

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 1019 - 11/11/2026 19:14:50    2700125

Link

Replying To otgarom:  "Imagine David Clifford, Ryan O'Donoghue, Sam Mulroy, Jack Carney, Jack McCarron, Oisín O'Neill, etc. Are lining up a two pointer or have got a step on their man outside the arc, what is their man going to do? Obviously foul them if the free will only be worth one, with players like that the result is nearly guaranteed to be a net positive for the defending team over the course of a game/season.

Also, 2 points up in the last minute of a game, a team is outside the arc, trying to work a two pointer, just foul them and go man to man for the free, trying to retain and get controlled possesion from a free kick is far harder and more time consuming than doing so from open play.

Getting two points for a free might be seen as too much of a punishment but it's very much q nessecery evil."
The 2 pointer was probably the one rule change that made the most difference. 3 up and solo and go the next most influential changes.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 21026 - 11/11/2026 20:13:42    2700133

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "The 2 pointer was probably the one rule change that made the most difference. 3 up and solo and go the next most influential changes."
I'd say it is the 3 up rule and kickoff rule that have made the most change.
To be honest, I'm still not sure the 2 pointer is actually needed, the 3 up rule on its own may have been enough to disincentivise defensive football.

GreenMan1987 (Meath) - Posts: 148 - 15/11/2026 09:29:59    2700410

Link

Replying To GreenMan1987:  "I'd say it is the 3 up rule and kickoff rule that have made the most change.
To be honest, I'm still not sure the 2 pointer is actually needed, the 3 up rule on its own may have been enough to disincentivise defensive football."
The kick off rule is a good change too!

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 21026 - 15/11/2026 12:25:45    2700419

Link

Looks like a good few of the 2026 rules are progressing to congress.

1. An extension of the 40-metre arc to the end-line
2. Two-points for all scores outside the 40-metre arc, apart from 45s
3. Four points for a goal
4. Sideline free-kicks will be taken from on or behind the sideline rather than behind it
5. If a player takes a kick-out mark (claims/does not claim) and is subsequently illegally challenged within his four-metre space, the sanction is a 50m penalty. In both cases the player may choose to take the free-kick from outside the 40m arc
6. 13m frees awarded for dissent/abuse from a member of a backroom team, kick-out infractions or a breach sanction. For both the dissent/abuse and breach infractions the player may choose to take the free-kick from outside the 40m arc
7. Substitutes to be increased from five to six (to be excluded from Ryan Cup trial)
8. Denial of a goalscoring opportunity inside the 20m line, but not within 25m of each sideline or within the semi-circular arc, will bring a black card or red card


the below are likely canned
1. No scores by hand - fist or open - other than in-flight score
2. A limit on consecutive hand-passes to three, with a foot motion - apart from a solo - required on the fourth pass
3. A backcourt rule where a team cannot play the ball back across the halfway line into their own half
4. All kick-outs must cross the 13m arc rather than the 40m arc

There is another change coming down the tracks once integration goes through - removing the small arc (centred on the 21m line) and replacing it with a 31/33m arc centred on the goal line. That arc can be used for penalty exclusion zones and as the 2 point arc in ladies football.

tirawleybaron (Mayo) - Posts: 2064 - 17/11/2026 12:28:49    2700584

Link

Replying To tirawleybaron:  "Looks like a good few of the 2026 rules are progressing to congress.

1. An extension of the 40-metre arc to the end-line
2. Two-points for all scores outside the 40-metre arc, apart from 45s
3. Four points for a goal
4. Sideline free-kicks will be taken from on or behind the sideline rather than behind it
5. If a player takes a kick-out mark (claims/does not claim) and is subsequently illegally challenged within his four-metre space, the sanction is a 50m penalty. In both cases the player may choose to take the free-kick from outside the 40m arc
6. 13m frees awarded for dissent/abuse from a member of a backroom team, kick-out infractions or a breach sanction. For both the dissent/abuse and breach infractions the player may choose to take the free-kick from outside the 40m arc
7. Substitutes to be increased from five to six (to be excluded from Ryan Cup trial)
8. Denial of a goalscoring opportunity inside the 20m line, but not within 25m of each sideline or within the semi-circular arc, will bring a black card or red card


the below are likely canned
1. No scores by hand - fist or open - other than in-flight score
2. A limit on consecutive hand-passes to three, with a foot motion - apart from a solo - required on the fourth pass
3. A backcourt rule where a team cannot play the ball back across the halfway line into their own half
4. All kick-outs must cross the 13m arc rather than the 40m arc

There is another change coming down the tracks once integration goes through - removing the small arc (centred on the 21m line) and replacing it with a 31/33m arc centred on the goal line. That arc can be used for penalty exclusion zones and as the 2 point arc in ladies football."
The only change worth keeping was that kickouts would cross the 13m arc rather than the 40m mark.

icehonesty (Wexford) - Posts: 2601 - 17/11/2026 14:32:21    2700597

Link

Replying To otgarom:  "Imagine David Clifford, Ryan O'Donoghue, Sam Mulroy, Jack Carney, Jack McCarron, Oisín O'Neill, etc. Are lining up a two pointer or have got a step on their man outside the arc, what is their man going to do? Obviously foul them if the free will only be worth one, with players like that the result is nearly guaranteed to be a net positive for the defending team over the course of a game/season.

Also, 2 points up in the last minute of a game, a team is outside the arc, trying to work a two pointer, just foul them and go man to man for the free, trying to retain and get controlled possesion from a free kick is far harder and more time consuming than doing so from open play.

Getting two points for a free might be seen as too much of a punishment but it's very much q nessecery evil."
I'd add that the threat of a 2 point free has kept the game moving. Without this as a potential sanction there would be a return to seeing loads of fouls slowing the game down just outside the 45.

brianb (Kildare) - Posts: 515 - 17/11/2026 15:03:35    2700603

Link

https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2026/1119/1599758-the-game-isnt-suffering-walsh-warns-of-rule-changes/

Seems like the majority of players are against any further changes. I think a lot of fans are more or less happy with the way things are also tbh.

Fionn (Dublin) - Posts: 5360 - 19/11/2026 10:37:29    2700749

Link

Replying To Fionn:  "https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2026/1119/1599758-the-game-isnt-suffering-walsh-warns-of-rule-changes/

Seems like the majority of players are against any further changes. I think a lot of fans are more or less happy with the way things are also tbh."
The GAA appointed a big name Committee who had to justify themselves by throwing out a load of proposals.
Agree with Shane Walsh about the hand points, skill less, ugly and illogical and inconsistent seeing as you can't score goals that way.

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 1019 - 19/11/2026 12:02:07    2700766

Link

Bit off topic but I see Shane Walsh thinks the GAA needs to go semi professional. We can't do it for the love of the game anymore he says. I could
Not disagree more. Pay for play would destroy the GAA.

yew_tree (Mayo) - Posts: 12328 - 19/11/2026 13:14:55    2700781

Link

Delighted that the most egregious proposals, handpass limits, no handpass points and the backcourt aren't going anywhere, hope the 4 point goal fails too but its the big change that I hate the least.

otgarom (Mayo) - Posts: 56 - 19/11/2026 14:21:38    2700792

Link

Replying To icehonesty:  "The only change worth keeping was that kickouts would cross the 13m arc rather than the 40m mark."
I totally agree regarding kickouts only having travel pass 13 meter it keeps players thinking and that's what we need not robots playing,, the 4 point for goal in my opinion bad as now teams will just sit players around square not to concede goal and then. Sit more around arc and no one will care about conceding a point it's almost an irrelevant score anymore in my opinion it will bring back ultra defensive football again ,, just when players ,, referees and supporters were getting used of all rule change they had set up another football committee full of egos to destroy our game ,,

Kickitout (Galway) - Posts: 1195 - 19/11/2026 14:52:56    2700794

Link

A fisted point needs a certain amount of skill but a hand passed point needs no skill whatsoever.Its too easy.The handpassing has become tiresome and is more like basketball now.I know its hard for a ref to count the hand passes but players handpassing over and back the park in boring and also skillless.

brayballer (Wicklow) - Posts: 824 - 19/11/2026 15:33:33    2700796

Link

Replying To brayballer:  "A fisted point needs a certain amount of skill but a hand passed point needs no skill whatsoever.Its too easy.The handpassing has become tiresome and is more like basketball now.I know its hard for a ref to count the hand passes but players handpassing over and back the park in boring and also skillless."
Slapping a ball into the net is the worst of the lot.

Fionn (Dublin) - Posts: 5360 - 19/11/2026 17:13:05    2700801

Link