Meath Forum

Senior Championship

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To royler:  "Referee made an error in the summerhill v donash game, hill player won a mark, however handed the ball to another team mate who kicked a point, I think another player can take the kick but can't score directly ?"
Player who wins the mark must take it, unless they are injured in winning the mark, then their nearest teammate takes responsibility

Belt (Meath) - Posts: 272 - 09/09/2024 11:20:56    2569047

Link

Replying To royler:  "Referee made an error in the summerhill v donash game, hill player won a mark, however handed the ball to another team mate who kicked a point, I think another player can take the kick but can't score directly ?"
Player who wins the mark must take it, unless they are injured in winning the mark, then their nearest teammate takes responsibility

Belt (Meath) - Posts: 272 - 09/09/2024 12:12:26    2569056

Link

Replying To Belt:  "Player who wins the mark must take it, unless they are injured in winning the mark, then their nearest teammate takes responsibility"
But the nearest team mate cannot score directly as Eoghan Freyne did on Saturday. Point should not have been allowed.

kingofclubs (Meath) - Posts: 330 - 09/09/2024 12:15:18    2569060

Link

Replying To kingofclubs:  "But the nearest team mate cannot score directly as Eoghan Freyne did on Saturday. Point should not have been allowed."
Score can still be taken by the second player, even if he didn't claim the mark. Nothing in rule book to stop it

Belt (Meath) - Posts: 272 - 09/09/2024 13:19:16    2569075

Link

Replying To Belt:  "Score can still be taken by the second player, even if he didn't claim the mark. Nothing in rule book to stop it"
Rule states "If the referee determines that the player who makes the 'mark' has been injured in the process and is unable to take the kick, the referee shall direct the player's nearest team mate to take the kick but he may not score directly from the kick." Eoghan Frayne scored directly from the kick which contravenes this rule. It was also very significant in that it meant that Ashbourne then had to go for goal at two points down rather than take a point opportunity to draw the match which would have qualified them.

kingofclubs (Meath) - Posts: 330 - 09/09/2024 14:07:15    2569089

Link

Replying To kingofclubs:  "Rule states "If the referee determines that the player who makes the 'mark' has been injured in the process and is unable to take the kick, the referee shall direct the player's nearest team mate to take the kick but he may not score directly from the kick." Eoghan Frayne scored directly from the kick which contravenes this rule. It was also very significant in that it meant that Ashbourne then had to go for goal at two points down rather than take a point opportunity to draw the match which would have qualified them."
Are you looking at the latest version of the rulebook? The "but he may not score directly from the kick" is no longer in there

Belt (Meath) - Posts: 272 - 09/09/2024 15:31:37    2569107

Link

Replying To kingofclubs:  "Rule states "If the referee determines that the player who makes the 'mark' has been injured in the process and is unable to take the kick, the referee shall direct the player's nearest team mate to take the kick but he may not score directly from the kick." Eoghan Frayne scored directly from the kick which contravenes this rule. It was also very significant in that it meant that Ashbourne then had to go for goal at two points down rather than take a point opportunity to draw the match which would have qualified them."
Isn't the rule anymore , official rule book says " a score may be awarded"

Faithfulmeath (Meath) - Posts: 13 - 09/09/2024 16:42:13    2569125

Link

Someone else can take the kick, must be an old rule book that you are looking at.

Nothingbutthetruth (Meath) - Posts: 67 - 10/09/2024 12:06:46    2569238

Link

After three rounds you would be right if you thought the top scorer in the Senior championship played in the game on Sunday where Ratoath had a cricket score, but wrong if you thought it was a Ratoath player because it is Keith Curtis of Rathkenny on 0-20 (11frees), however Ratoath's Cian Rogers is the top scorer from play with 3-8 (17).

madmeath (Meath) - Posts: 83 - 11/09/2024 21:01:29    2569459

Link

Replying To madmeath:  "After three rounds you would be right if you thought the top scorer in the Senior championship played in the game on Sunday where Ratoath had a cricket score, but wrong if you thought it was a Ratoath player because it is Keith Curtis of Rathkenny on 0-20 (11frees), however Ratoath's Cian Rogers is the top scorer from play with 3-8 (17)."
As rathkenny only got 11points did Keith Curtis kick points for Ratoath as well

Ashrules (Dublin) - Posts: 549 - 13/09/2024 13:05:09    2569700

Link

Replying To Ashrules:  "As rathkenny only got 11points did Keith Curtis kick points for Ratoath as well"
Obviously this is a total after the 3 group games (Trim, Skryne and Ratoath). Keith Curtis is another player who our former Senior manager deemed not good enough to warrant any significant game time over the past two seasons despite being one of the best performing forwards in the county in that time.

BigJoe14 (Meath) - Posts: 997 - 13/09/2024 13:28:36    2569707

Link

Replying To Ashrules:  "As rathkenny only got 11points did Keith Curtis kick points for Ratoath as well"
Think you missed the point. Keith is top scorer over the 3 group games not for one game…

SillySimonsOpinion (Meath) - Posts: 60 - 13/09/2024 13:47:11    2569710

Link

Heard talk that Conor Nash trained with Simonstown in an in house match during the weekend. He is also listed on their 13 man list for senior clubs. a massive boost to them if he is back but is there any truth in it?

COUNTYTOCOUNTY (Meath) - Posts: 30 - 17/09/2024 09:59:35    2570304

Link

Replying To COUNTYTOCOUNTY:  "Heard talk that Conor Nash trained with Simonstown in an in house match during the weekend. He is also listed on their 13 man list for senior clubs. a massive boost to them if he is back but is there any truth in it?"
Hawthorn lost in the afl at the weekend and there year is done, so possibly could be true.

lough4life (Meath) - Posts: 5 - 17/09/2024 14:55:58    2570404

Link

Replying To COUNTYTOCOUNTY:  "Heard talk that Conor Nash trained with Simonstown in an in house match during the weekend. He is also listed on their 13 man list for senior clubs. a massive boost to them if he is back but is there any truth in it?"
Is he allowed to play hence he has signed a new contract in Oz ?

thelutch (Meath) - Posts: 1072 - 17/09/2024 15:53:30    2570413

Link

Replying To thelutch:  "Is he allowed to play hence he has signed a new contract in Oz ?"
I do remember he almost lost the contarct when they won it in 2017!! i am sure that time has moved on and they would be more than accepting of him playing this year. If he is i could see simonstown being genuine contenders

COUNTYTOCOUNTY (Meath) - Posts: 30 - 17/09/2024 17:00:00    2570429

Link

Having lost their 1st round game in Ashbourne and having almost been beaten by Dunshaughlin in Ashbourne in last years QF, Ratoath immediately complained to the County Board (CCC) to get their QF against Dunshaughlin moved out of Ashbourne and within 24 hours the County Board relented even though less than 24 hours earlier Meath GAA were promoting it on their website, as the big crowd puller under lights on the Saturday night in Ashbourne.
In any case it appears changing the venue location to Pairc Tailteann didn't seem to bother Dunshaughlin, probably as they have a decent enough record in Pairc Tailteann and at this stage are confident of taking on Ratoath regardless of the venue.
For Ratoath it could yet turn out to be a case for "Be careful what you wish for".

madmeath (Meath) - Posts: 83 - 17/09/2024 17:31:04    2570436

Link

Replying To madmeath:  "Having lost their 1st round game in Ashbourne and having almost been beaten by Dunshaughlin in Ashbourne in last years QF, Ratoath immediately complained to the County Board (CCC) to get their QF against Dunshaughlin moved out of Ashbourne and within 24 hours the County Board relented even though less than 24 hours earlier Meath GAA were promoting it on their website, as the big crowd puller under lights on the Saturday night in Ashbourne.
In any case it appears changing the venue location to Pairc Tailteann didn't seem to bother Dunshaughlin, probably as they have a decent enough record in Pairc Tailteann and at this stage are confident of taking on Ratoath regardless of the venue.
For Ratoath it could yet turn out to be a case for "Be careful what you wish for"."
How do you know that they asked for it to be changed?? I don't think Ratoath have an issue with Ashbourne all their lads have won games there plenty of times! I also reckon Dunshaughlin don't care where they play them - don't know for sure but I suspect Dunshaughlin are a younger and probably fitter team!

I think it makes sense to change it - I'd say it will attract the biggest crowd of the weekend and I'm not sure Ashbourne is great for getting in and out of especially with the road works in the town at the moment!

Makes sense to have 2 double headers in PT in my opinion! Easier for county board to manage

Royalblufill (Meath) - Posts: 511 - 17/09/2024 20:21:49    2570473

Link

Replying To madmeath:  "Having lost their 1st round game in Ashbourne and having almost been beaten by Dunshaughlin in Ashbourne in last years QF, Ratoath immediately complained to the County Board (CCC) to get their QF against Dunshaughlin moved out of Ashbourne and within 24 hours the County Board relented even though less than 24 hours earlier Meath GAA were promoting it on their website, as the big crowd puller under lights on the Saturday night in Ashbourne.
In any case it appears changing the venue location to Pairc Tailteann didn't seem to bother Dunshaughlin, probably as they have a decent enough record in Pairc Tailteann and at this stage are confident of taking on Ratoath regardless of the venue.
For Ratoath it could yet turn out to be a case for "Be careful what you wish for"."
I would imagine this is complete nonsense and the reason it's moved to PT is to make it easier for clubber who are showing a game from there on Saturday and Sunday

LeitrimRoyal99 (Meath) - Posts: 1521 - 18/09/2024 08:34:59    2570502

Link

Replying To Royalblufill:  "How do you know that they asked for it to be changed?? I don't think Ratoath have an issue with Ashbourne all their lads have won games there plenty of times! I also reckon Dunshaughlin don't care where they play them - don't know for sure but I suspect Dunshaughlin are a younger and probably fitter team!

I think it makes sense to change it - I'd say it will attract the biggest crowd of the weekend and I'm not sure Ashbourne is great for getting in and out of especially with the road works in the town at the moment!

Makes sense to have 2 double headers in PT in my opinion! Easier for county board to manage"
Spoke to two Ratoath lads and they were moaning about Ashbourne. Mentioned they had a poor record there and suddenly its changed. As regards access, there would be no problems with Ashbourne on a Saturday evening. The clubs stewarding is second to none. They ran a blitz for u11 two weeks ago and it was like clockwork. Superb day. I have no affiliation to them, just an envious neighbour. Their grounds are always in superb condition and its a pity they are not rewarded. Personally would of preferred to play there than PT in latter years. PT is undoubtedly a better surface to play on but that's as far as it goes.

Greensheen (Meath) - Posts: 58 - 18/09/2024 08:35:49    2570503

Link