National Forum

Fermanagh GAA thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Win in Ardee and we are safe in Div 2 simple … I actually felt Donnelly was being cagey today and had one eye on championship in a few weeks !
Armagh clearly a div 1 level side

KeshGFC (Fermanagh) - Posts: 334 - 03/03/2024 22:42:35    2529594

Link

Replying To SkeaLad:  "I agree with that assessment...dullest to watch...Fermanagh should have went for it and been more ambitious and should have thrown the kitchen sink at it, just like Cork did last week...what had they to lose??"
SkeaLad - match was awful to watch, Armagh missed a stack and should have run away with it. Unfortunately Fermanagh's inability to break tackle or fear of turn over, amounted to keep ball, with the goal keeper, probably having the most time on the ball. Disappointed with skill set on show, and poor passing, expected better from county players

Blitzkrig (Fermanagh) - Posts: 39 - 04/03/2024 15:57:15    2529760

Link

Although the frustration from the Armagh match may have eased it is still in the mind, the lack of ambition and exerted effort to push to overturn a 4 point deficit was non existent and very disappointing,if going to lose at least have a proper cut at it with shackles off and give the supporters something to shout about.

It was as if happy with scoreline and team feel that will be safe enough with away games against Louth and Cavan offering us 2 points!

Before the campaign began it fair to say on PAPER Louth away looked best chance of a win, but matches arent won on paper and given how league has transpired its going to be a tough fight to get anything in Ardee. Louth have performed well and been unlucky in narrow defeats to Armagh/Meath and in Sam Mulroy, have a forward capable of kicking 8-10 points alone, something we dont have.

While depending on this weekend Cavan could still have a chance of promotion going into our final game in Breffni Park, even last year when they had nothing to play for in last game and we had all on line we just about beat them in last 5 minutes and from last year looks like Cavan stronger and Fermanagh have lost few players, so dont think in position to assume points there either. Taking both into account this makes last weekend white flag waving last 15 minutes in our last home game more annoying, Armagh didnt even break a sweat, they be a different animal in 4 weeks time.

I hope im wrong in this thinking and we can get result on St Patricks day but unless we have Ryan Lyons, Conor Love, Johnny Cassidy, Breen back in squad its hard to see it at moment, Sean Cassidy will have to be back in starting 15 also.

macca999 (Fermanagh) - Posts: 1097 - 11/03/2024 12:33:28    2530731

Link

Replying To macca999:  "Although the frustration from the Armagh match may have eased it is still in the mind, the lack of ambition and exerted effort to push to overturn a 4 point deficit was non existent and very disappointing,if going to lose at least have a proper cut at it with shackles off and give the supporters something to shout about.

It was as if happy with scoreline and team feel that will be safe enough with away games against Louth and Cavan offering us 2 points!

Before the campaign began it fair to say on PAPER Louth away looked best chance of a win, but matches arent won on paper and given how league has transpired its going to be a tough fight to get anything in Ardee. Louth have performed well and been unlucky in narrow defeats to Armagh/Meath and in Sam Mulroy, have a forward capable of kicking 8-10 points alone, something we dont have.

While depending on this weekend Cavan could still have a chance of promotion going into our final game in Breffni Park, even last year when they had nothing to play for in last game and we had all on line we just about beat them in last 5 minutes and from last year looks like Cavan stronger and Fermanagh have lost few players, so dont think in position to assume points there either. Taking both into account this makes last weekend white flag waving last 15 minutes in our last home game more annoying, Armagh didnt even break a sweat, they be a different animal in 4 weeks time.

I hope im wrong in this thinking and we can get result on St Patricks day but unless we have Ryan Lyons, Conor Love, Johnny Cassidy, Breen back in squad its hard to see it at moment, Sean Cassidy will have to be back in starting 15 also."
you are normally a rational enough poster lad but Id disagree with your list of players that we need back.
I mean Lyons yes fair enough and Cassidy would be massive. Love is an excellent club player but not yet delivered at county level and Breen has been a massive servant to county for years but hasnt really made an impact on games in quite a while if those 4 were available only 2 would ever be pushin to start . Would you not be hoping to see McGurn back too ?
Anyway I honestly think we approached that game like we were eyeing up championship in a few weeks and Im glad to see that ambition from Donnelly.
Surely its the easiest semi that we could hope for in ulster in manys a long year if we turn over Armagh. Its a huge ask as Armagh have quality all over the field and a strong bench too but hell we should be treating that round 1 championship game like our biggest match since ulster final. It would explain all the starter changes v armagh in league.

So I agree we didnt want to win that game v Armagh, but I dont think it was from lack of ambition

KeshGFC (Fermanagh) - Posts: 334 - 11/03/2024 17:15:39    2530789

Link

Kesh GFC

Yes agree verdict on Love at this level yet to be seen as hasnt got run of games between injury and dropping out, think he could offer more of a potential score threat than others currently on field if playing. As Sean Quigley highlighted last year, sadly most intercounty teams want athletes not footballers, obviously speed and running power is key but for the scoreboard needs a balance. Breen has been a super servant and know may not be at level of 2018 but has the ability to kick a score and be option from bench(which is light, highlighted by reluctance to make changes until late in games)


Be delighted to see McGurn back,most of all though know that he isnt in equation even of a return for the league due to hip injury it seems so thats why didnt reference him for Louth game as know not possible. He is a huge miss as a target man and scoring ability.


There is no doubt if somehow beat Armagh great opportunity and need to be ready for what is going to be huge task but at same time cant sacrifice league status for this either, was just lack of intensity in last 15 minutes that was hard to watch as a supporter.

With Munster championship draw, good chance Clare will reach munster final meaning that even 6th in Division 2 wont play in Sam Maguire this summer. As Fermanagh supporter id be more than happy with staying in Division 2 and playing the tailteann cup as dont think be ready for a Sam Maguire group, even looking at division 3 this year not sure we would get promoted if in it. However do feel its crucial for teams development to stay in Division 2.


Hopefully a good turnout in Ardee on Sunday(be prepared for a different county ground setting)

macca999 (Fermanagh) - Posts: 1097 - 12/03/2024 12:49:19    2530893

Link

Replying To macca999:  "Kesh GFC

Yes agree verdict on Love at this level yet to be seen as hasnt got run of games between injury and dropping out, think he could offer more of a potential score threat than others currently on field if playing. As Sean Quigley highlighted last year, sadly most intercounty teams want athletes not footballers, obviously speed and running power is key but for the scoreboard needs a balance. Breen has been a super servant and know may not be at level of 2018 but has the ability to kick a score and be option from bench(which is light, highlighted by reluctance to make changes until late in games)


Be delighted to see McGurn back,most of all though know that he isnt in equation even of a return for the league due to hip injury it seems so thats why didnt reference him for Louth game as know not possible. He is a huge miss as a target man and scoring ability.


There is no doubt if somehow beat Armagh great opportunity and need to be ready for what is going to be huge task but at same time cant sacrifice league status for this either, was just lack of intensity in last 15 minutes that was hard to watch as a supporter.

With Munster championship draw, good chance Clare will reach munster final meaning that even 6th in Division 2 wont play in Sam Maguire this summer. As Fermanagh supporter id be more than happy with staying in Division 2 and playing the tailteann cup as dont think be ready for a Sam Maguire group, even looking at division 3 this year not sure we would get promoted if in it. However do feel its crucial for teams development to stay in Division 2.


Hopefully a good turnout in Ardee on Sunday(be prepared for a different county ground setting)"
fair enough and by the way that Louth match is down for 2pm Sat by the way
if you think about, we'd need to avoid a loss to louth on sat even if we'd beaten armagh....so thats the only thing i can think of that gives logic to all the changes and lack of ambition in final 10. Because if it isnt that then Id be seriously worried

KeshGFC (Fermanagh) - Posts: 334 - 12/03/2024 13:10:22    2530896

Link

Would it be worth giving Malachy ORourke a shout ?? Shameful stuff today

KeshGFC (Fermanagh) - Posts: 334 - 16/03/2024 15:16:53    2531371

Link

Replying To KeshGFC:  "Would it be worth giving Malachy ORourke a shout ?? Shameful stuff today"
Haha all he would do is shout back ….

veterngaa (Monaghan) - Posts: 384 - 17/03/2024 09:44:22    2531607

Link

Maybe give Rory a call

PattyONeill (Derry) - Posts: 220 - 17/03/2024 13:03:36    2531641

Link

Victory tonight over Cavan too little too late. The hiding fromLouth last week the difference between survival and relegation ultimately the decisive factor.

Jack L (None) - Posts: 3099 - 23/03/2024 20:44:44    2532928

Link

Sickening. Fantastic performance but unfortunately 5 points, which normally would be enough, not enough for Fermanagh this year. Hopefully that win will spark confidence into them heading into championship! A lot of positives I believe from this campaign though and many lessons learned for a young squad.

Bailah (Fermanagh) - Posts: 43 - 23/03/2024 20:50:49    2532934

Link

Fair play to lads for putting louth game behind them and doing their job against cavan. Always nice to beat another northeren team even though cavan had nothing to play for. Shame kildare could not have done us a favour, but you make your own luck unfortunately we just did not make enough. If your going to down you might as well go down swinging and they put a fight.

It was by far G. Jones best game in a green Jersey man of the match. The pass for the goal was great more of that please not sure where the cavan defence was for it though.
We could had a 3rd goal as it open up for Shane mcgullion.

Worrying thing was we where up by 9points at 1 stage and I still did not feel fully confident we where going to win that game. Cavan had hit numerous wides and when they threw on some of their bigger players they had reduced the deficit quite quickly.

It's disappointing to be going back to division 3 but they had their chances to stay up could have beaten meath and should have been Cork but there is still plenty of positives to be taken from the league.

1. Young squad they will have learnt a lot from the year and physically they will be stronger next

2. We ranked up some big scores 2.14 cavan 2.10 kildare .16 Cork

3. We found a goal threat. For years felt like we did not create enough goal scoring opportunities or players were afraid to have a go at goal.

4. Only 3 home games

At the start of the year I was wondering were wins where going to come from at all so to get 5 points is good just not enough. I do believe would have stayed up if we had recognised free taker Sean quigley leaving Lyons and mcgurn injuried. R.jones was also a big lost.

Me personally I think donnelly is doing a good job.
I have a different view than him on the role of a goalkeeper but it's the modern way.
I would like him to use the squad a wee bit more roation wise and make subs a bit quicker at times.
Still want to see more long, direct kicks going forward.

Hopefully we can get a run in the championship/ Cup.

Seperate note heard pundits talking before some game about possible rule changes in the future for example a shot clock (no from me), that you have to leave so many players in the opposition half (yes).
I would remove squareball, black card and mark. I would introduce frees have to go forward, i would make a sideline ball worth 2 points cause think its a dying art. Your only 3 hand passes in a row before you have to kick it. To many slow sides ways hand passes which makes the game dull to watch and discourages Young ones

What changes to rules would yous make?

ERNEDEVIL (Fermanagh) - Posts: 68 - 24/03/2024 22:57:31    2533385

Link

Ernedevil great post, measured, constructive and evidence to support views given.

After a brilliant conclusion with the league finals time to look back on Fermanaghs campaign, great that lads bounced back in Breffni last week after the horror show in Ardee, would have been easy to lie down but the young squad showed some resolve, ultimatley wasnt enough, the Cork game was the killer in the end, at time even felt like that cold be costly defeat and so if proved. Decky McCusker was excellent, McDade very good, while Garvan Jones had his best ever game in a green jersey, showed ability to pick a pass too with Cassidys goal.


Donnelly says happy with campaign, with the loss of Sean Quigley and Ryan Jones was always going to be tough, then injuries to Ryan Lyons, McGurn and Johnny Cassidy proved costly especially given only 3 home games.
So for a young team they definitely will have learned alot against strong opposition and should stand to them going forward, shame couldnt stay in Division 2 next year to further push their development and Division 3 will be a dogfight next year as always.

Looking ahead now to the Ulster Championship, a huge test v Armagh in 2 weeks, the recent league encounter showed just how tough it will be for Fermanagh to get get through to semi final. Would like to see more support in Brewster as numbers at games havnt been great this year and we all know how Armagh bring huge support.

Would agree that Donnelly will need to use bench more going forward, very slow to do this in league(which maybe shows lack of faith in squad)especially if players back from injury such as Love, Lyons and Breen has greater options then, certainly think McMahon should be a started in role of sweeper and allow Cassidy man mark and allow McGullion revert to wing back role. Armagh could have scored 3 gaols last month in league so cant allow this again or be a long day.

The target for summer should be a semi of the Tailteann Cup and maybe push on from there.


Separately the system again is in limelight after league finals, personally think its a joke that 2 teams from Division 3 arent guaranteed to play in Sam Maguire due to the provincial draw in Munster enabling Clare a likely final. Then in Kildare reach leinster final Westmeath lose out still, surely they should at least set up a playoff game between Down and Clare with winner getting into Sam, gives both teams a chance then.

macca999 (Fermanagh) - Posts: 1097 - 01/04/2024 11:20:49    2534955

Link

The lack of chat here on week of an Ulster "Championship " further reiterates the how unlike Championship it really is, following on from last weekends low key non atmospheric opener between Cavan and Monaghan. Weather, pitches, crowds, non of it is close to what Championship is about.


Anyway looking ahead to the game it's a tall ask ahead for Fermanagh. Armagh won in first gear in league recently and if get same goal chances Sunday it be curtains.
Fermanagh need to go long with kickouts and pack middle to win breaks, Armagh will push high if go short and drive turnovers otherwise.


Hope to see few late changes with McMahon and Johnny Cassidy, good to see McGurn on bench even.if is only able for 5 minutes after lay off, pity Lyons not available. Hopefully we can keep it tight until final straight then throw the sink at it.

Armagh will bring big support as always, let's hope Fermanagh fans turn up in numbers too..

macca999 (Fermanagh) - Posts: 1097 - 12/04/2024 22:48:44    2537593

Link

The silence and lack of interest shown here on the week of a championship game is a fair reflection of the low level of interest the championship is generating across the board, the GAA have contributed greatly to the downfall of the championship. Jarlath Burns is the white hope that can hopefully redeem it to its glory.

However thats a bigger issue, time to focus on ourselves after Sundays sorry display.
We all knew going into the game that Fermanagh faced a huge task against Armagh, their scoring threat and physical strength, Fermanagh had players starting who probably wouldnt make the Armagh panel so that outlined the challenge ahead. The lack of Fermanagh support again in the stands maybe reflects the lack of belief and maybe interest in team unfortunately at the moment

From league and games this season we knew what to expect, however on Sunday we persisted with slow short restarts on kickouts inviting Armagh to press and force high turnover, playing into Armaghs hands while for long kicks outs failed to get bodies in around the play to try win any breaks to get vital possession.

Watching the attempts at times in middle, could see in players eyes and efforts lack of belief and genuine effort to win the ball, one handed efforts, jumps were almost tokenistic. Would never have any issue with better team winning a game and always hold hands up but the lack of intensity and hunger is never acceptable especially at home in a Championship match. One of the players said after game that let their manager down, hard to argue on that point.

Kieran Donnelly is a great Fermanagh man, both as player and manager, has a good record to date from club and schools, plus got Fermanagh to division 2 and has undoubtedly the respect of all players and gaels, so wouldnt want to come out and criticise players publicly but to say that Fermanagh were "solid" in defence couldnt be further from the truth and to use the black card of Kelm as reason for the collapse is a bit of cover excuse. Armagh were breaking tackles at ease and could take on man at will and beat them for speed and power, their ability to move ball fast meant players 2/3 seconds ahead and Fermanagh were always reacting. The warning signs have been there all season, Louth in League was best example, Fermanaghs slow play invites turnovers which leaves defence totally exposed. Surprised that James McMahon wasnt in team, especially in sweeper role to try and stop the goal threat.
On the day Decky McCusker and Fionan O Brien were the best performers, Kelm tried until end and was probably very frustrated at times as he didnt have many others supporting when he had ball though his lack of shooting threat was evident and he had few solo efforts which highlighted this. The attacking threat was non existent, fact that only scored 2nd point in injury time shows this, when look through team from previous year, we are now relying on 2 players who weren't starters last year to be our main scorers this year shows that cutting edge is limited currently.

Where to from here, well firstly id say few players could be tempted to head to the states, the dollars could tempt them rather than playing infront of 750-1,000 people in Tailteann Cup games.

Team will have a few weeks to reflect on Sunday and reset for Tailteann Cup, vitally would hope the likes of McGurn and Johnny Cassidy will get up to match fitness as need them in team, while id like to think that James McMahon, Conor Love, Tiarnan Bogue would come into the team also. Hopefully Ryan Lyons might be able to feature in the group games also.

macca999 (Fermanagh) - Posts: 1097 - 16/04/2024 19:08:00    2538408

Link

Replying To macca999:  "The silence and lack of interest shown here on the week of a championship game is a fair reflection of the low level of interest the championship is generating across the board, the GAA have contributed greatly to the downfall of the championship. Jarlath Burns is the white hope that can hopefully redeem it to its glory.

However thats a bigger issue, time to focus on ourselves after Sundays sorry display.
We all knew going into the game that Fermanagh faced a huge task against Armagh, their scoring threat and physical strength, Fermanagh had players starting who probably wouldnt make the Armagh panel so that outlined the challenge ahead. The lack of Fermanagh support again in the stands maybe reflects the lack of belief and maybe interest in team unfortunately at the moment

From league and games this season we knew what to expect, however on Sunday we persisted with slow short restarts on kickouts inviting Armagh to press and force high turnover, playing into Armaghs hands while for long kicks outs failed to get bodies in around the play to try win any breaks to get vital possession.

Watching the attempts at times in middle, could see in players eyes and efforts lack of belief and genuine effort to win the ball, one handed efforts, jumps were almost tokenistic. Would never have any issue with better team winning a game and always hold hands up but the lack of intensity and hunger is never acceptable especially at home in a Championship match. One of the players said after game that let their manager down, hard to argue on that point.

Kieran Donnelly is a great Fermanagh man, both as player and manager, has a good record to date from club and schools, plus got Fermanagh to division 2 and has undoubtedly the respect of all players and gaels, so wouldnt want to come out and criticise players publicly but to say that Fermanagh were "solid" in defence couldnt be further from the truth and to use the black card of Kelm as reason for the collapse is a bit of cover excuse. Armagh were breaking tackles at ease and could take on man at will and beat them for speed and power, their ability to move ball fast meant players 2/3 seconds ahead and Fermanagh were always reacting. The warning signs have been there all season, Louth in League was best example, Fermanaghs slow play invites turnovers which leaves defence totally exposed. Surprised that James McMahon wasnt in team, especially in sweeper role to try and stop the goal threat.
On the day Decky McCusker and Fionan O Brien were the best performers, Kelm tried until end and was probably very frustrated at times as he didnt have many others supporting when he had ball though his lack of shooting threat was evident and he had few solo efforts which highlighted this. The attacking threat was non existent, fact that only scored 2nd point in injury time shows this, when look through team from previous year, we are now relying on 2 players who weren't starters last year to be our main scorers this year shows that cutting edge is limited currently.

Where to from here, well firstly id say few players could be tempted to head to the states, the dollars could tempt them rather than playing infront of 750-1,000 people in Tailteann Cup games.

Team will have a few weeks to reflect on Sunday and reset for Tailteann Cup, vitally would hope the likes of McGurn and Johnny Cassidy will get up to match fitness as need them in team, while id like to think that James McMahon, Conor Love, Tiarnan Bogue would come into the team also. Hopefully Ryan Lyons might be able to feature in the group games also."
I agree macca, while Donnelly's accomplishments indeed merit respect, it is crucial to scrutinise performances objectively.

To assert that Fermanagh's defence was "solid" in light of Sunday's championship game seems a stretch beyond reason. Football, as with any sport, demands a critical eye, free from the shackles of undue allegiance. Acknowledging shortcomings does not diminish Donnelly's legacy but rather underscores the need for improvement.

Furthermore, attributing the team's collapse to include the black card incident involving Kelm appears to divert attention from deeper issues. While unfortunate, such incidents are part of the game, and a resilient team should overcome them. To label it as a "cover excuse" belies the truth of the situation Fermanagh found themselves,.

Constructive criticism, offered with respect and honesty, fosters growth within any team. Donnelly's stature should not shield him from this essential aspect of football discourse. It is through such dialogue that progress is achieved, both on and off the pitch.

abc1234 (Fermanagh) - Posts: 405 - 17/04/2024 10:44:23    2538529

Link