Replying To shaggykev:  "I think having the draw before provincial finals has one major benefit. It gives fans 3-4 weeks notice on next game.

Tickets, planning trips with friends etc.
The six day turnaround is never ideal and hurts prelims and quarter final attendances. Every match should have at least two weeks notice.

Tomorrow is strange but it still gives fans almost two weeks planning whereas after round 2 it's week on week. Round 2A winners know they'll be going to Croke Park two weeks later but don't even know whether it's a Saturday or Sunday.

Going to games is expensive so every bit of foresight is welcome. I think it's one of the biggest reasons Munster hurling is so well attended.

As for provincial finalists not getting benefits, you get home field advantage, know your next opponents afterwards and can treat final for what it is. That cup to be won. I doubt teams will take to final to lose as it will have no impact. It's a stand alone trophy and I think you'll find 3 of the 4 champions really cherished their trophy."

Replying To gbay:  "does anyone no if fionn mcdonagh is part of the panel and where did james macloughlin go from moycullen?"

Replying To CiarraiMick:  "Oh 3 out of 4 and which county did nt cherish their trophy?
1.Kerry wanted to win the Munster cup this year more than any as its a new cup and its called "The Paidi O Se" cup.Motivation was never as high and the win was inmensely cherished.

2.Westmeath.No reply needed !

3.Armagh.They wanted an Ulster title and they deserved one more than any cointy after the heartache of penalty shoot outs and boy did they cherish it.

4.Roscommon. Brilliant scenes afterwards and huge celebrstions.Def cherished their win."