|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 12 Like(s)
I see more player bashing posts citing the manager as blameless, yet my response has not published as I guess it was too hard-hitting being genuinely honest about what I think of management and my support for our team players wo give so much to Fermanagh GAA. Whether these posters like it or not the buck stops with the manager! I'm quite sure there are similar minded honest people who feel I am correct then they are welcome to like my comment. Now I'm off to work where some of my earnings go to Club Eirne and to the manager that is failing us!
BigToeJoe (National) - 19/05/2023 08:36:34
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 9 Like(s)
Replying To The_Rat: "With Harte now freed from Derry our co board should be on the phone right now and invite him to take the Fermanagh manager's job. And Donnelly should do the decent and stand aside immediately." Great news!!! Time for sharp decision-making so that our Fermanagh lads will get the best of the best!
BigToeJoe (National) - 08/07/2024 16:56:35
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 7 Like(s)
Replying To cillnaile.: "Macca reminds me of my grandpa's donkey as when things were going good eating fresh carrots he was boastous but when the feeding was sub standard he would kick back with hind legs. Similarly, Macca is all praise for Fermanagh for now but if they lose badly in the next games he will lambast players as happened last season with his over-the-top criticism of goalkeeping which caused uproar on this forum. So his dismissive, if not arrogant, response to wired2themoon was unwarranted." Brilliant cillnaile!! I was this morning thinking when I read your post of the donkey riding his tandem to Ederney for the game on Saturday!! Anyway what I came on about is it looks like I'll have to fork out 36 euros for my Mrs, my two U16 children and myself which is a bit of a tall order given that it's not even likely that we will get seats never mind shelter if it's raining. Ok there may be limited numbers allowed because of the small facility but charging 8 euros each for a children aged 5 and 7yrs old is a bit over the top, no wonder they are called Grab All Association!!
BigToeJoe (National) - 13/03/2023 10:46:36
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 3 Like(s)
I was astonished to see my yesterday afternoon posting vanishing into the ether! It appears my genuine view of the current Fermanagh team management and the disastrous season under its watch cannot be aired for debate on this GAA forum.
It seems my attempt to initiate an honest discussion about the state of the Fermanagh team has been stifled. My concerns regarding the team's performance and the effectiveness of its management are valid points of interest for supporters and followers of the GAA. However, it appears that some topics are off-limits, or perhaps certain criticisms are deemed too controversial to remain visible.
The Fermanagh team's season has been less than stellar, marked by a series of disappointing performances and questionable decisions from the management. As a passionate fan, I believe it is essential to discuss these issues openly, to understand where things went wrong and how improvements can be made. Constructive criticism is a cornerstone of progress, and airing these views should be part of a healthy dialogue within the GAA community.
Meanwhile, other forum contributors such a macca999, Itown1234, Kesh GFC, etc., are permitted to be brutal with their criticism without censorship. Yet, the disappearance of my post suggests a different reality. It raises questions about the openness and inclusivity of the forum. Are we truly encouraged to share our perspectives, or is there an unspoken rule against challenging the status quo? If the latter is true, it undermines the very spirit of the GAA, which thrives on the passion and engagement of its supporters.
This experience has left me pondering the balance between maintaining a positive Fermanagh GAA community atmosphere and allowing free expression. It is my hope that we can find a way to embrace both, ensuring that all voices, even the critical ones, have a place in the conversation. After all, the ultimate goal is the betterment of the team we all support.
BigToeJoe (National) - 28/06/2024 09:48:57
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 3 Like(s)
Replying To macca999: "I just asked a simple question if anyone had update on how the Lissan project went since fundraiser as hasnt been much in press etc, im sure other people who purchased a ticket would appreciate update of its progress?
So sorry to disappoint your latest theory but ive no issue with location of it,just hoping its moving forward as our county teams from underage to senior in all codes need it badly.
As for Mickey Harte, dont think he would take such a job if opportunity arose and severly doubt county board be in a position to support it.
Looks like alot of county jobs be available with few departures already,im sure either way be confirmation soon from Kieran Donnelly" I feel sorry for you mate. A pot-stirrer in denial won't wash with those who a clever enough to see through you. When it comes to others calling for management change, you are indecisive clinging to your fence-sitting crutch and you are dismissive of other people's suggestion and lack the capability to offer any constructive way forward for our senior county team who have been so disadvantaged by an incapable management. In fact, if truth be told, you represent no one, and I mean NO ONE, other than yourself!!
BigToeJoe (National) - 09/07/2024 13:36:16
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 3 Like(s)
Replying To cillnaile.: "FT result Leitrim 2-7 Fermanagh 1-19. The manager is beginning to earn his money having used the right gameplan making player changes that helped. However, things got a bit alarming at the beginning of the second half with two quick goals from the bogmen but thankfully that momentum wasn't sustained. The result should queiten Macca like the ass as he will hopefully do less kicking of the hind legs such as after the Wexford game." Brilliantly summed up!! Well done players. That should silence macca999 & co as the Kinawley poster put it... the donkey has been fed a generous amount of rations so no need of kicking and bashing of our players. Hey Antrim watch out!
BigToeJoe (National) - 21/05/2023 09:52:22
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 3 Like(s)
So how will Enniskillen townie team do tomorrow evening against the Kilcoo village team? I will be shocked if the Ernesiders progress to the Ulster Club senior final as much as I was stunned to see them through to the Fermanagh final. I make no apologies for my statement as I know quite a sizeable GAA base in our county think the same unlike some including the previous poster are simply being two-faced by licking up to the Gaels club.
BigToeJoe (National) - 25/11/2022 13:46:07
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 3 Like(s)
macca999, in spite of your U-turn about Donnelly staying on and your notion of walking away if he stayed on, it's seems clear you're still invested in Fermanagh's success, but annoyingly your analysis is still rather long-winded, as always. However, while it's fair to highlight concerns like the midfield and defensive gaps, I think some of the criticism risks missing the bigger picture. First off, this was always going to be a tough challenge against a strong Kildare team. The lack of depth in midfield is a structural issue that can't be fixed overnight. McGurn stepping in shows the management is trying to adapt, even if it comes with trade-offs elsewhere. Similarly, Che Cullen's commitment, despite being based in Cork, deserves recognition rather than scepticism about his availability...it's players like him who show the dedication needed at this level. As for the crowd size, it's disappointing to see a drop-off in support, but instead of focusing on that, we should be rallying behind the team for the crucial home games ahead. The lads need support now more than ever, especially in what is shaping up to be a highly competitive division. Let's look forward to the opportunities for improvement rather than dwelling too much on what went wrong in one game. With four home fixtures, there's a real chance to turn things around, and the supporters can play a key role in lifting the team's spirit.
P.S. On another note, it's surprising that you chose to head off to Kildare instead of staying to help those in need after the storm. Many of our GAA members were out supporting the community during a difficult time...wouldn't your efforts have been better spent lending a hand locally? It's what the GAA spirit is all about!
BigToeJoe (National) - 28/01/2025 22:02:21
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 2 Like(s)
Replying To KeshGFC: "There are 2 or 3 of us that come on and offer comments on football .. good bad or misinformed they are opinions.. seems most people choose to come on here to comment on comments… please give views on football .. don't make it personal .. I mean what's the point … as this is the Fermanagh gaa thread not the Fermanagh pundit bashing thread !!" First of all, Kesh man get your facts correct. I do comment on football with plenty of evidence of that especially club football! However, if I wish to respond to a poster who makes an excellent comparison about views of another and in doing uses analogies of donkey or an ass to make his point, then that poster is entitled to do so!! Now that your are such a great GAA supporter, do you condone the charging of eight euros each to primary school aged children like my own?? which by the way you conveniently ignored in your response!!
BigToeJoe (National) - 14/03/2023 10:51:50
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 2 Like(s)
Replying To Itown1234: "Stick to the football or go back to the Cavan thread.
Do you have any thoughts or opinions on Fermanagh this year?" Well said!! Why do I get the feeling that KeshKFC and Foolsgold are in fact macca999 in disguise given his reputation as a multiuser poster?
BigToeJoe (National) - 16/03/2023 09:56:15
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 2 Like(s)
Replying To Bailah: "With the greatest of respect, it's not Donnely's fault that Cullen had a complete brainf**t in the lead up to the penalty and subsequent goal. I know panic set in, but if McNally just would have received the pass at least you would only be conceding a point from a free and not a goal + black card. Let's face it, that was the big turning point of the game, you can't blame Donnelly for it.
Everything else up until that point was going fine." All I can say Bailah is that you and macca need educated on the core of Fermanagh's problem i.e. employing lower tier management ...so you get what you pay for.
BigToeJoe (National) - 16/05/2023 16:39:44
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 2 Like(s)
Replying To macca999: "Quiet on here in midst of business end of the club championship.
Kinawley be very disappointed to lose Saturday after being 7 points up midway through second half but failed to score again, Derrygonnelly have a wealth of experience and it certainly helped.
Yesterday Erne Gaels raced out of the traps and did enough to keep the Gaels at bay.
Should be a good final, only a week turnaround which could have impact if either team carrying knocks.
Erne Gaels will be very hungry and will want to avenge last year's final loss while Derrygonnelly always tough opponent plus would like another crack at Kilcoo after recent ulster final, after their antics at weekend certainly be lots of support for the fermanagh champions in that one.
Ulster intercounty championship draw just around corner now too on Saturday." Overall, what a boring championship season which largely produced a standard below par which sums up our Fermanagh club football. As far as the personnel behind both club and county footie they seem more focussed on who can create the best facilities as opposed to the creation of best teams, leaving players that don't measure up to their capability. So. for macca999 yapping about Ulster club championship is a farce.
BigToeJoe (National) - 22/10/2023 23:12:47
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 2 Like(s)
I shared my honest and valid opinion, only to be met with dismissal by someone unwilling to consider another perspective. As for his Cavan associate, his curiosity about certain players and their club, with all due respect, is a matter that doesn't concern him.
BigToeJoe (National) - 30/01/2025 15:45:45
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 1 Like(s)
Replying To cillnaile.: "hey man u r very full of itself tonight but I would remind you that Ekn Gaels r only as good as their last game and ur assumption that they will oust the Cavan champions so easily out of the Ulster's is wishful thinking. Enjoy ur year will the new York cup as it might be a while before it's filled with the townies brew again!" I doubt if Enniskillen Gaels would be senior champions if they had to meet Kinawley in the final? In a controversial finish in the semi final Kinawley were denied that chance to become champions.
BigToeJoe (National) - 01/11/2022 09:54:00
|
|
Fermanagh Club Championships - 1 Like(s)
Replying To fman123: "Lug, I think there is an argument to suggest a change the structure to the senior, intermediate and junior championships is neccessary. With the leckers beating ederney in the championship and teams like the gaels coming up from division 2 and finishing in the top 4... its clear the gap from division 1 and 2 isnt as wide as in previous years.
What I would propose is the following:
Based on the previous league season placings.
Senior & Intermediate Championships
An open draw with 16 teams, division 1 + the top 6 teams in division 2. The winners of the first round ties advance to the quarter finals, the 8 losing teams go into the intermediate championship and both championships are played with an open draw format to a finish.
Junior Championship
The bottom 4 teams of division 2 play off in a simple semi final format to decide the final and ultimately the champions.
I think the proposal above has a number of positives.
First of all it gives more teams the chance to compete for the new york gold cup. Secondly It eliminates these needless relegation play off games which are a bit of a joke to be honest. It should also make the leagues more competitive, particulary in division 2 to try and avoid those bottom 4 places. Finally the championship games would be played in neutral venues which would mean the hosting club would get a nice tidy gate." Seems a plausible idea worth exploring as it would stimulate competitiveness but would the mindset of the current conservative county board be open to it? I doubt it. It appears to me if it was that all press reports be compulsory written up in Irish would be of more interest to them than a new and practical way of revamping the championships to create a more attractive structure. Just look at their website and the fixtures/results are all in Irish - distorted vision - that's the hurdle you would be facing.
BigToeJoe (Fermanagh) - 21/08/2019 14:06:58
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 1 Like(s)
Replying To Bailah: "Really poor collapse today. A common theme this season where we have let commanding positions slip due to unforced errors. We should be putting teams like Wexford away quite easily based on who we have beaten already this year. I suppose championship football is a different ball game but we should have been out the gate mid way through the second half.
A win next week against Leitrim is a must now, obviously." Totally agree with you...Fermanagh should have put Wexford to bed earlier on in the game but through their own fault rather than any great football by the yellowbellies made it a draw. No excuses from macca I hope and speaking of excuses in a current GAA controversary I noticed a kind of an apology from macca in a previous post
BigToeJoe (National) - 15/05/2023 11:30:38
|
|
Fermanagh Manager - 1 Like(s)
Not to be disrespectful BigToeJoe but there are alot of Non county standard players in that list
Gary McKenna - Derrygonnelly
Hard worker and suits the Harps system but has never sign of being a county standard player
Daire O'Cathain-Kinawley
Big and tall and that's about it. Not a very powerful or athletic player
Eddie Courtney - Aghadrumsee
Didn't work the first won't work the second time
Danny Leonard - Derrylin
Good player for a very poor Derrylin side , easy to stand out
Finbar Gillen - Ederney very light and small for a wing half back! Suits ederney to the ground but his first call up didn't work out
Jason Flanagan - Newtownbulter
Tiarnan Bogue - Tempo
Good player but injuries hit him after school level! Never really became a stand out senior player
Rory McCaffery - Tempo"
A shadow of his former self! A great youth football with plenty of speed and strength! Seemed to slow down loads due to injury
Potential players who could play county in my opinion
Chris Snow
Sean McManus
Cameron Mcbrien
Jack McCann
Tomas Corrigan
Conor love
Allaboutclub (Fermanagh) - Posts: 62 - 30/07/2019 11:37:11
Right lad, I don't like YOUR ATTITUDE/COMMENTS aimed at certain players. I listed players that I felt merited looking at for inclusion in a incoming manager's squad. All of these players have earned it in my view and deserve a start or new start. I agree with shotgun that such incoming players should be kept on the squad for a lengthy period to up skill them to county level before ant cull takes place.
I notice you have included a past goalkeeper in your list which gives us a clue to who's posting!
BigToeJoe (Fermanagh) - 30/07/2019 18:24:39
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 1 Like(s)
Replying To Bailah: "Fermanagh v Laois in Prelim, can see this very much being a shootout similar to last years league game. Both teams have good forwards but leaky defences. Need to ensure a good crowd the make sure we get a big result. Championship is about momentum and we haven't had any since the league final defeat.
A big result this weekend hopefully changes that." Agree with leaky analysis for sure. Donnelly not getting the problems sorted yet again! Let's hope the players step up on Saturday evening against Laois. With a home game might give us and the players hope but it will be down to the manager to sort the shortcomings. By the way I see the goalie bashing scribe macca is very silent at the moment!
ps. yes Coa Lug, I agree, a bad result and for your information Laois finished 3rd in the NFL division 4 this year so you know what that means...Fermanagh should be the victors this weekend.
BigToeJoe (National) - 06/06/2023 10:09:35
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 1 Like(s)
Replying To Itown1234: "It's strange that your post was taken down. I think I speak for most on this forum when I say that no posts should be removed. We're a small community, and there's no need to make it smaller.
Regarding your points on healthy dialogue, I don't believe any of my criticism has been unfair. I still support Donnelly and would be happy to see him continue for another season. Additionally, I rarely criticize the players because we all know they are the best the county has, and their commitment to playing for Fermanagh is like a full-time job that many couldn't even imagine doing.
If the criticism you're referring to is about Lissan, I think it's completely valid. We've had plenty of time to either pick a new site or renovate Lissan. While facilities don't make good teams, they can generate interest, provide better resources, and boost morale.
Always happy to hear everyone's views, BigToeJoe. I hope to hear more from you in the future." Thanks for your comment, Itown1234. In your case, it might have been more helpful if I had said that your criticism had been constructively bruising rather than outright brutal. Certainly, KeshGFC's assessment was extremely harsh, but that's to be expected given his consistently destructive nature and lack of constructive input. As for the pot-stirrer macca999, he pretends to be nice to Donnelly while being disingenuous, much like in Shakespeare's play where Mark Antony repeatedly calls Brutus an honourable man while ultimately betraying him. macca999's history of uncomplimentary remarks about players and indeed managers is well documented. Hopefully, this clarifies why I mentioned you and your fellow forum contributors regarding the removal of my critical post about the outcome of this season for our poorly managed Fermanagh team.
BigToeJoe (National) - 02/07/2024 10:16:02
|
|
Fermanagh GAA thread - 1 Like(s)
Fully agree. Very embarrassing to watch, especially the pathetic Teemore effort!!!
BigToeJoe (National) - 05/11/2023 21:55:53
|