National Forum

How Do We Take Hurling On From Here

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To tirawleybaron:  "I love to get a contract with you as the client.

The cost materials to cover a full size GAA pitch is about 30/m2 = €350,000
An existing junior club ground will have carpark, dressing rooms, bit of a stand/terrace, lights

All a contractor has to do is strip the topsoil and put in the sand subbase - then roll our the material

Its a €500-600k job if the club buys the materials (avoiding the contractors mark up on materials) - a top quality lighting system is €50k.
If you did in in the summer it would all be done for €600k max.

€5m per weaker county
16 counties - €80m
money better spent than doing up Pairc Ui Chaoimh for €110m to fill it twice a year."
Right, here goes.

Viking's club put in a small astro area recently at the price he outlines above. My own club is currently looking at developing an astro area of 60m x 40m (2,400 sq. m.). That's about one-fifth the size of a full GAA pitch (based on a full pitch being 140m x 85m = 11,900 sq. m.)

Our quote from our preferred tenderer is €183,000. Times that by five for a full-sized pitch, and you'd get €915,000.

Have had a detailed look at the quote, and turns out you're correct that the price of the synthetic surface alone is in the region of €30 per sq. m. The price we're being quoted is €28.50 plus VAT. But you're vastly underestimating the cost of everything else when you say "all a contractor has to do is ........"

Examples from our own quote include almost €8,000 for initial earthworks, almost €10,000 for drainage, more than €40,000 for bases of stone & grit, almost €5,000 for kerbing, and almost €20,000 for a shock pad system. There are several other things too.

Overall, the cost of the "all a contractor has to do" things add up to almost twice the price of the synthetic surface itself. So, I stand by my assertion that the cost of installing a full-size 4G pitch would be in the region of €1 million. The cost of the synthetic surface itself might "only" be about €350,000 but the overall cost of going from a grass pitch to a 4G one would be around €1 million.

I repeat that these are prices from our preferred tenderer. Other tenders we received were higher.

Also, you're way off on the price of lights, if you think that a "top quality" system can be installed for €50k. You're talking closer to €300k for LED floodlights of the required standard for hurling (and you won't get planning permission these days for anything other than LED lights). A club near me installed lights a couple of years ago and I know for a fact the cost was in the region of €275k - I assume it's gone up a bit in the meantime.

Finally, let's just say all this money was found, and a club somewhere did indeed hand over a pitch for development as a 4G facility. Has it occurred to you - what's that club to do when the pitch is needed for matches or anything else involving other clubs, but they have squads who want to train at that time too? You'd basically be shutting them out of their own ground.

Pikeman96 (Wexford) - Posts: 3384 - 27/02/2025 15:23:33    2593513

Link

Replying To Pikeman96:  "Right, here goes.

Viking's club put in a small astro area recently at the price he outlines above. My own club is currently looking at developing an astro area of 60m x 40m (2,400 sq. m.). That's about one-fifth the size of a full GAA pitch (based on a full pitch being 140m x 85m = 11,900 sq. m.)

Our quote from our preferred tenderer is €183,000. Times that by five for a full-sized pitch, and you'd get €915,000.

Have had a detailed look at the quote, and turns out you're correct that the price of the synthetic surface alone is in the region of €30 per sq. m. The price we're being quoted is €28.50 plus VAT. But you're vastly underestimating the cost of everything else when you say "all a contractor has to do is ........"

Examples from our own quote include almost €8,000 for initial earthworks, almost €10,000 for drainage, more than €40,000 for bases of stone & grit, almost €5,000 for kerbing, and almost €20,000 for a shock pad system. There are several other things too.

Overall, the cost of the "all a contractor has to do" things add up to almost twice the price of the synthetic surface itself. So, I stand by my assertion that the cost of installing a full-size 4G pitch would be in the region of €1 million. The cost of the synthetic surface itself might "only" be about €350,000 but the overall cost of going from a grass pitch to a 4G one would be around €1 million.

I repeat that these are prices from our preferred tenderer. Other tenders we received were higher.

Also, you're way off on the price of lights, if you think that a "top quality" system can be installed for €50k. You're talking closer to €300k for LED floodlights of the required standard for hurling (and you won't get planning permission these days for anything other than LED lights). A club near me installed lights a couple of years ago and I know for a fact the cost was in the region of €275k - I assume it's gone up a bit in the meantime.

Finally, let's just say all this money was found, and a club somewhere did indeed hand over a pitch for development as a 4G facility. Has it occurred to you - what's that club to do when the pitch is needed for matches or anything else involving other clubs, but they have squads who want to train at that time too? You'd basically be shutting them out of their own ground."
Im a contractor myself - the rates in Wexford are better than anywhere else btw.
Also, rates per m2 improve with scale of project.

Its the top half of the county this would take place and up here there are lots of NI contractors who will work for half nothing.
If thats the kind of money needed for hurling lights - ye shouldn't be allow play outside of March to October.
There also must be no nocturnal animals within 5 miles of a hurling field.

Anyway - the plan would be to use a junior clubs field - In most rural counties - there are lots of junior clubs that have amalgamated and now have two pitches - they alternate matches between both grounds - just take one of them for a 4 g pitch and let them use it for football when there is not hurling on.

Bearing in mind my proposal is to increase the no of hurling clubs in Mayo from 4 to 8 - they wont exactly be hogging the pitch from dawn to dusk - 24/7 not a runner due to ridiculous cost of hurling lights and their negative impact on nesting birds, and nocturnal animals.

tirawleybaron (Mayo) - Posts: 1706 - 27/02/2025 17:14:18    2593540

Link

Replying To tirawleybaron:  "Im a contractor myself - the rates in Wexford are better than anywhere else btw.
Also, rates per m2 improve with scale of project.

Its the top half of the county this would take place and up here there are lots of NI contractors who will work for half nothing.
If thats the kind of money needed for hurling lights - ye shouldn't be allow play outside of March to October.
There also must be no nocturnal animals within 5 miles of a hurling field.

Anyway - the plan would be to use a junior clubs field - In most rural counties - there are lots of junior clubs that have amalgamated and now have two pitches - they alternate matches between both grounds - just take one of them for a 4 g pitch and let them use it for football when there is not hurling on.

Bearing in mind my proposal is to increase the no of hurling clubs in Mayo from 4 to 8 - they wont exactly be hogging the pitch from dawn to dusk - 24/7 not a runner due to ridiculous cost of hurling lights and their negative impact on nesting birds, and nocturnal animals."
With all due respect, if you're a contractor myself, you're not one who's involved with floodlights in any way.

You were already way off with the cost of them, and you don't seem to realise either that there are all sorts of regulations governing "light spillage" and the like, such that floodlights don't unduly interfere with wildlife or neighbouring properties or nearby traffic, etc.

Also wondering about another aspect of your proposal. You now say it's with the aim of increasing the number of hurling clubs in Mayo from four to eight. But yet you wanted one of these pitches "in every barony" - i.e. nine designated 4G hurling pitches altogether.

A cynic might suggest however that it's easy to answer that one, if you're such a contractor yourself. Looking for extra work and few more quid????? :)

Pikeman96 (Wexford) - Posts: 3384 - 27/02/2025 18:13:44    2593550

Link

Replying To tirawleybaron:  "Im a contractor myself - the rates in Wexford are better than anywhere else btw.
Also, rates per m2 improve with scale of project.

Its the top half of the county this would take place and up here there are lots of NI contractors who will work for half nothing.
If thats the kind of money needed for hurling lights - ye shouldn't be allow play outside of March to October.
There also must be no nocturnal animals within 5 miles of a hurling field.

Anyway - the plan would be to use a junior clubs field - In most rural counties - there are lots of junior clubs that have amalgamated and now have two pitches - they alternate matches between both grounds - just take one of them for a 4 g pitch and let them use it for football when there is not hurling on.

Bearing in mind my proposal is to increase the no of hurling clubs in Mayo from 4 to 8 - they wont exactly be hogging the pitch from dawn to dusk - 24/7 not a runner due to ridiculous cost of hurling lights and their negative impact on nesting birds, and nocturnal animals."
At the end of the day why do we need state of the art astros and lights to set up a hurling club?

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 18679 - 27/02/2025 19:26:24    2593566

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "At the end of the day why do we need state of the art astros and lights to set up a hurling club?"
Lol. Exactly.

The Mayo man was the one who suggested all these 4G facilities would help. I ended up getting dragged into how the price of them means that wouldn't be realistic. I should probably have just asked your question in the first place! Especially since he said in one of his last posts, after he found out about the sort of floodlights needed for hurling, that hurling should be confined to March to October anyway. Nowhere near as pressing a need for 4G pitches during those months. :)

Fact of the matter is that these things are not a case of "build it, and they will come". This ain't Field of Dreams, baby. There's either the will and the interest in any given area to promote and develop hurling, or there's not. Even the best facilities in the world won't change that.

Pikeman96 (Wexford) - Posts: 3384 - 27/02/2025 22:10:50    2593598

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "At the end of the day why do we need state of the art astros and lights to set up a hurling club?"
Far from astros and floodlights I was raised.

I remember having to move a crushed can of Dutch gold to take a penalty in a rackard league game. Honestly a true story.

Doylerwex (Wexford) - Posts: 4300 - 27/02/2025 22:32:04    2593605

Link

Replying To Doylerwex:  "Far from astros and floodlights I was raised.

I remember having to move a crushed can of Dutch gold to take a penalty in a rackard league game. Honestly a true story."
Ah yes the joys of growing up in the 80s and 90s! It's probably worse these days, syringes and the like.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 18679 - 28/02/2025 10:17:16    2593645

Link

https://x.com/i/status/2029544432639315977

It is being lamented that hurling only has 5 games after the provincial championships. The preliminary quarter finals including Joe Mac finalists have only just been scrapped. The Munster CEO has shared his disapproval of 4 going through from Munster. One of the Wexford guys on here while initially in favour, thought the better of it.

Are GAA HQ going to seek to include 4th placed teams in the knockout stage... Wouldn't put it past them voting it in later in the year.

legendzxix (Kerry) - Posts: 9513 - 05/03/2026 16:02:04    2660149

Link

Replying To legendzxix:  "https://x.com/i/status/2029544432639315977

It is being lamented that hurling only has 5 games after the provincial championships. The preliminary quarter finals including Joe Mac finalists have only just been scrapped. The Munster CEO has shared his disapproval of 4 going through from Munster. One of the Wexford guys on here while initially in favour, thought the better of it.

Are GAA HQ going to seek to include 4th placed teams in the knockout stage... Wouldn't put it past them voting it in later in the year."
It wont get in. Hardly anyone outside Waterford wants that.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 18679 - 05/03/2026 16:17:28    2660156

Link

Cut out overcarrying and throwing would be a great start. There's far too much 'ballcarrying', throwing , grossly excessive step taking, and short passing in the modern possession driven game of hurling, and to be honest, this game isn't a patch on the spectacle it was when teams didn't give a toss about possession.

Pope_Benedict (Galway) - Posts: 4596 - 05/03/2026 17:34:12    2660178

Link

Replying To Pope_Benedict:  "Cut out overcarrying and throwing would be a great start. There's far too much 'ballcarrying', throwing , grossly excessive step taking, and short passing in the modern possession driven game of hurling, and to be honest, this game isn't a patch on the spectacle it was when teams didn't give a toss about possession."
Tell Refs to enforce the rules.
Stop castigating refs who try to do so.

A lad took a line ball in Nowlan Park last Sunday from about 2 metres inside the sideline.
In football encroaching when taking a sideline kick is always called out by officials.

Seanfan (Roscommon) - Posts: 405 - 06/03/2026 09:16:11    2660233

Link

Replying To Pope_Benedict:  "Cut out overcarrying and throwing would be a great start. There's far too much 'ballcarrying', throwing , grossly excessive step taking, and short passing in the modern possession driven game of hurling, and to be honest, this game isn't a patch on the spectacle it was when teams didn't give a toss about possession."
I agree on all of that. The problem is the possession retention style will absolutely annihilate the older traditional style if we're talking about two fairly evenly matched teams ability wise. So teams would be mad not to play the way we're seeing currently.
Until the current method is made more difficult to play, as you said by enforcing rules properly (not an easy task at times) or by adjusting the rules as we saw with football, we'll continue to see more of it.

WanPintWin (Galway) - Posts: 2738 - 06/03/2026 11:04:11    2660263

Link

Replying To Pope_Benedict:  "Cut out overcarrying and throwing would be a great start. There's far too much 'ballcarrying', throwing , grossly excessive step taking, and short passing in the modern possession driven game of hurling, and to be honest, this game isn't a patch on the spectacle it was when teams didn't give a toss about possession."
I've tried my best to get into hurling and see why everyone was raving about it being the best or fastest game in the world etc or whatever they were saying about it, but as a spectator sport I find it impossible to get into.
I know it's different if you grew up with it and played it and the skill levels are fantastic no doubt but to watch it for me I just cannot get into it.
The new rules in football have made it a far far better spectator sport than hurling imo.

Tirchonaill1 (Donegal) - Posts: 3733 - 06/03/2026 11:38:31    2660269

Link

Replying To Pope_Benedict:  "Cut out overcarrying and throwing would be a great start. There's far too much 'ballcarrying', throwing , grossly excessive step taking, and short passing in the modern possession driven game of hurling, and to be honest, this game isn't a patch on the spectacle it was when teams didn't give a toss about possession."
Prefer what Im watching now to what I was watching in the 90s truth be told. Hurling is way faster now, and the skill levels are higher. Some of the blood and thunder from those days has gone for health and safety reasons, its not just because teams are trying to retain the ball better.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 18679 - 06/03/2026 11:46:42    2660272

Link

Replying To Seanfan:  "Tell Refs to enforce the rules.
Stop castigating refs who try to do so.

A lad took a line ball in Nowlan Park last Sunday from about 2 metres inside the sideline.
In football encroaching when taking a sideline kick is always called out by officials."
The rules for sidelines are different in hurling and football, but in hurling they should be taken from the line. Football is behind the line.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 18679 - 06/03/2026 11:47:45    2660273

Link

Replying To Viking66:  "Prefer what Im watching now to what I was watching in the 90s truth be told. Hurling is way faster now, and the skill levels are higher. Some of the blood and thunder from those days has gone for health and safety reasons, its not just because teams are trying to retain the ball better."
There is no hurling skill involved in taking too many steps to run past opponents, and this 'skill' is fairly rampant in the modern game. Throwing the ball to a teammate probably is a skill, but it's illegal in the rules. The modern game is ravaged with these two eyesores, and if they were clamped down on, it would give defenders a much better opportunity to defend, rather than having to endure the absurd level of scoring that goes on in most hurling games these days.

Pope_Benedict (Galway) - Posts: 4596 - 06/03/2026 14:23:16    2660315

Link

Replying To Pope_Benedict:  "There is no hurling skill involved in taking too many steps to run past opponents, and this 'skill' is fairly rampant in the modern game. Throwing the ball to a teammate probably is a skill, but it's illegal in the rules. The modern game is ravaged with these two eyesores, and if they were clamped down on, it would give defenders a much better opportunity to defend, rather than having to endure the absurd level of scoring that goes on in most hurling games these days."
DJ Carey took about 13 steps to score a goal to knock us out of Leinster in 1991. His 1st ever championship goal I think. Actually it was 6, but 13 sounds better for the story, 1 better than the usual 12 steps in the telling of the story. He named his favourite 10 goals once sometime before he retired, and the 5 that he ran with the ball all involved more than 4 steps.

Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 18679 - 06/03/2026 15:10:25    2660321

Link