SFC relegation semi final: Heartbreak for Meath Hill as Simonstown edge thriller on penalties

September 15, 2025

Meath Hill's Ryan Owens

Meath Hill and Simonstown served up a dramatic relegation semi-final under the Castletown lights on Friday evening, where conditions and heavy tension combined to produce a contest that had everything – goals, long-range points, extra-time drama, and ultimately the cruelty of penalties.

Meath Hill burst into life from the throw-in, with Cormac Sheehy clipping over inside the opening minute after Gary Breslin was fouled. Moments later, James Mooney turned defence into attack with a surging run before lofting a ball into the square that Jack McMahon palmed to the net – a dream start for the Hill. Simonstown were slow to settle but gradually worked their way into the game. Goalkeeper Ben Hoey got them off the mark with a confidently struck 21-metre free, while Aaron Farrelly almost raised a green flag only to be denied by superb pressure from Dominic Yorke. Despite chances falling at both ends, Breslin’s monster two-pointer and a tidy close-range score kept Meath Hill in control at the break.

Half-Time: Meath Hill 1-04 Simonstown 0-02

Simonstown, though, emerged rejuvenated after the restart. A two-pointer from their first attack signalled intent, and soon a string of scores – including another booming effort from Hoey – had them in front for the first time. Meath Hill steadied themselves through Sheehy and Breslin, but when Simonstown conjured a goal from nothing, the pressure was cranked up another notch. Refusing to wilt, Meath Hill clawed their way back into the contest. Ryan Owens and Breslin were central to their revival, with the latter nerveless from placed balls. In a frenetic finish, Breslin slotted the equaliser to force extra-time.

Full-Time: Meath Hill 1-11 Simonstown 1-11

The extra-time exchanges were just as fierce. Pierce McGrath’s point gave Meath Hill the edge before Simonstown responded with another two-pointer. Breslin’s accuracy kept the sides deadlocked at the interval. As conditions worsened, both teams battled for inches. Breslin once more nudged Meath Hill in front, but deep into stoppage time Simonstown earned a close-range free. Hoey, already influential, stepped up and calmly slotted it over to drag the tie to penalties.

Extra-Time Full-Time: Meath Hill 1-14 Simonstown 1-14

In the shootout, Simonstown held their nerve to claim victory and condemn Meath Hill to the relegation final. For Meath Hill, it was a cruel end after a performance full of resilience and grit.

They now face St. Colmcilles in a do-or-die relegation decider on Friday, September 26th at 8pm in Dunganny.


Most Read Stories