Jack O'Shea made a suggestion on take your point yesterday evening that the GAA should consider an open draw every 3rd year, without the provincial championships. He didnt really go into specifics but I guess it'd be 2 defeats and your out.

What do people think? I'd be in favour I'd have to say. Long since tired of the provincial championships in both codes. Imagine Kerry v Dublin or Tipp v Kilkenny in May, now that would set the summer in action!

Pinkie (Wexford) - Posts: 4100 - 30/07/2012 15:40:08    1233701

sounds good but you want the best teams in final so seeding should be in place for the 1st round anyway

DownStar29 (Down) - Posts: 172 - 30/07/2012 15:45:57    1233707

Winning a Provincial championship is the best many countys will more than likely ever do so they have to be kept.

ormondbannerman (Clare) - Posts: 13473 - 30/07/2012 15:53:36    1233719

Pinkie
County: Wexford
Posts: 2148

1233701 Jack O'Shea made a suggestion on take your point yesterday evening that the GAA should consider an open draw every 3rd year, without the provincial championships. He didnt really go into specifics but I guess it'd be 2 defeats and your out.

the more pundits, the more ridiculous the suggestions

dhorse (Laois) - Posts: 11374 - 30/07/2012 16:00:54    1233733

downstars

why do you want seeding,

if it is truly open, then it must be open

cuchulainn35 (Armagh) - Posts: 1691 - 30/07/2012 16:02:26    1233738

Calling Omahant

dhorse (Laois) - Posts: 11374 - 30/07/2012 16:04:37    1233740

Well I think it would kill it if you had all the big teams out after 1st round. For example Dublin v. Donegal, Kerry v. Cork, Kildare v. Tyrone and also in hurling. Just well would rather see the big teams in a final on merit rather than well London v. Louth in an All Ireland Final. The chances of that happening would be slim but then again if you had all the big teams playing in first couple of rounds it could happen.

DownStar29 (Down) - Posts: 172 - 30/07/2012 16:08:59    1233747

Seeding could be based on league position? - If you remove the provincial champioships you better have something to replace it. Many teams and build and win a provincial crown - Roscommon, Sligo, Laois, Westmeath, Clare (95), Ulster has various winners but remove that and being real - these teams and the vast majority have nothing to aim for but only get as far in the race for sam as possible.

yew_tree (Mayo) - Posts: 12122 - 30/07/2012 16:10:42    1233750

DownStar29
County: Down
Posts: 50

1233747
Well I think it would kill it if you had all the big teams out after 1st round. For example Dublin v. Donegal, Kerry v. Cork, Kildare v. Tyrone and also in hurling. Just well would rather see the big teams in a final on merit rather than well London v. Louth in an All Ireland Final. The chances of that happening would be slim but then again if you had all the big teams playing in first couple of rounds it could happen.

Louth v London in the All Ireland final. Thumbs up for that.

OLLIE (Louth) - Posts: 12224 - 30/07/2012 16:31:57    1233783

I love a novel pairing for an All-Ireland final. I cant remember when we last had one in hurling, probably Wexford v Limerick 1996. In football probably Tyrone v Armagh was the last such pairing. By novel with none of the real traditional counties - Cork, Tipp, Kilkenny in hurling, Cork, Kerry, Dublin in football.

Pinkie (Wexford) - Posts: 4100 - 30/07/2012 17:08:58    1233840