(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post
I think the Meath full back line of 'Hands' and his corner men had a bit of extra help at the time. I remember listening to Michael O'Hehir's commentary on a Meath Mayo All-Ireland semi-final or final, and at one point he said that, 'the whole Hill of Tara' had come down on Mick Flanagan as he headed towards goal. O'Brien and Prendergast were outstanding full-backs.
neverright (Roscommon) - Posts: 1648 - 13/07/2017 15:37:41 2016144 Link 0 |
You'd want to get your facts straight. A Meath player playing in Dublin made himself available and a former Dublin underage player playing in Meath for the past 4 years made himself available. Crinigan (Meath) - Posts: 1319 - 13/07/2017 16:47:18 2016176 Link 0 |
Concentrate on your own county mate.. Stuart Lowndes - play his club football in Meath, folks are from Meath, pretty sure its common knowledge he always supported Meath. He played maybe two O'byrne cup matches and was then dropped off the panel. He's Eric's older brother but Eric always preferred Dublin Stephen O'Connor - folks are from Meath, played one trial match and it went no further.. It happens in every county and cuts both ways. Should a manager not pick the best players available to him We'd Michael Deegan playing for Donaghmore Ashbourne but was always on the Dublin panel. I believe a couple of lads from Ratoath were involved with Dubs underage too. Never a complaint from Meath folk about that.. brian (Meath) - Posts: 1954 - 13/07/2017 17:22:04 2016190 Link 0 |
So by your logic dean rock is a Meath player poached by dubs?
royaldunne (Meath) - Posts: 19449 - 13/07/2017 18:21:34 2016212 Link 0 |
Can I have some of what you smoking.
royaldunne (Meath) - Posts: 19449 - 13/07/2017 18:23:15 2016213 Link 0 |
If you want to compare teams to soccer. Dublin would be Barcelona Kerry would be Real Madrid . Meath would be Liverpool. Liverpool won 4 European Cups in 70s and 80S and have a great tradition. But find it hard to win in modern times. Meath won 4 All Irelands in 80s and 90s have a great tradition. But find it hard to win in modern times. Kildare would be Newcastle Utd. Both have passionate great supporters. Both were last the best team in the land in the 1920s. And both had 2 or 3 great years in the 90s. And both had one great year in the 90s when they could have won the big prize. But are rebuilding. Regards the two Dubs. They never played 1 minute or 1 second for Meath in championship or league. So its not an issue . You cannot criticize Meath for playing Dubs when they never played for the county for 1 second in league or championship. Listen many players have played for other counties. The greatest hurling goalkeeper of all time was Tony Reddan for Tipp. Yet he was a Galway man born and bred. Meath would not have a tradition of playing players from other counties. I know people will say Colm O Rourke but he was reared in Meath lived in Meath taught in Meath played all his club football in Meath. What I mean is Meath have never really had a Larry Tompkins. A player who played for another county. Kildare did seem to have policy of poaching other inter county players. Karl Dwywr was a Kerry footballer. Brian Lacey was a Tippearey footballer. Good luck to them.. I see no problem to much. Once a player lives or works in the county. But there was disquiet at the time when they tried to poach Declan Browne from Tipp and then Seanie Johnston fiasco brought it to farcical levels. Dwyer brought Cathal Sheridan onto the kildare panel in late 90s . Sheridan is one of the most successful footballer in Meath history winning senior under 21 minor and junior All Irelands with Meath. Bringing player from other counties with no link to their new county. Could be an issue. There was disquiet towards Kildare when Dwyer and McGeeney were bringing lacey and Johnston on board. I couldn't care less. Good luck to them. That Kildare 98 team was a brillant team. But as far as I can remeber Meath have not played 1 player in the championship in the last 30 years. Who played with another inter county team with the exception of Shane McAlinary and Ollie Murphy who but played for London in the championship. Many examples of player from other counties changing allegiance but there should be a link. That player is lIving or playing football in the county. Or have strong family connections eg Declan D'Arcy for Leitrim. Furlong1949 (Meath) - Posts: 1067 - 13/07/2017 18:31:05 2016217 Link 0 |
The fact is to say Meath have had no underage sucess is factually wrong. It is an 100% incorrect statement. Meath have had underage sucess in the traditional sense. Furlong1949 (Meath) - Posts: 1067 - 13/07/2017 19:37:59 2016244 Link 0 |
Here is a lIst of players from that All Ireland minor finalist Meath of 2012. 11 of that minor and sub bench have played senior for Meath. The manager Andy McEntee is now our senior manager. Furlong1949 (Meath) - Posts: 1067 - 13/07/2017 19:54:42 2016252 Link 0 |
The one massive problems for Meath and I would say Galway, since the blanket defence and sweeper system have been introduced neither county since 2001 have had real sucess. Meath have not played in a senior final in 16 years. Galway have not won a championship match in Croke Park in 16 years. Both counties past sucess was built on the traditional kick and catch game. Long balls in to the forward line. With the blanket defence and sweeper system . This style of play is not as effective. Counties that traditionally play a more short passing game, possession game have adapted better to the modern game. Both counties find it hard to play the modern way sweepers etc. There is no tradition in both counties of sweepers. And you can see when both counties get men behind the ball. And the players look lost at times. Furlong1949 (Meath) - Posts: 1067 - 13/07/2017 20:49:45 2016265 Link 0 |
I never said I had a problem with it, Roscommon have sourced players in Dublin too and like yourselves nothing worked it, I wasn't having a dig a Meath for it I was referring to the Meath poster who started on about Kildare and players from outside the county
Cuckoosinging (Roscommon) - Posts: 992 - 13/07/2017 21:52:18 2016279 Link 0 |
Probably, did I ever claim Leitrim were a footballing powerhouse ? I am a Meath man to the core, one of my parents is from Leitrim hence the name
LeitrimRoyal99 (Meath) - Posts: 1464 - 14/07/2017 00:41:59 2016332 Link 0 |
Correct in every aspect except for the fact that Eric used to support Meath. Went to school here and if you look at the Dublin GAA page his sporting hero is Trevor Giles funnily enough
LeitrimRoyal99 (Meath) - Posts: 1464 - 14/07/2017 00:42:59 2016333 Link 0 |
I am one of those young people. I was only 6 months old when we last won Sam so my time supporting them has been fairly bad to say the least. Still though in my life 3 Leinsters to Kildare's 1, 4 semi final appearances to Kildare's 2.
LeitrimRoyal99 (Meath) - Posts: 1464 - 14/07/2017 00:52:53 2016335 Link 0 |
You have 99 in your name so I assume you were born in 99 so I sincerely doubt you remember anymore than 1
tiobraid (Tipperary) - Posts: 4119 - 14/07/2017 08:08:18 2016345 Link 1 |
Ye lost though.... Tip won in 2011 and have 3-4 max playing senior now. One minor team will hardly make a great senior team... tiobraid (Tipperary) - Posts: 4119 - 14/07/2017 08:10:14 2016346 Link 0 |
Your right and your wrong. Yes we need to do what Tipp Roscommon Kildare Dublin Cavan footballers and Clare hurlers have done. And have underage sucess over a couple of years. We do need to follow that sucessful underage model. If we don't we are going nowhere fast. There has been allot of work being done recently. And if under 14 15 16 17 results are to go by . In the next few years we should be more sucessful in the new minor and under20 grades. Kildare and Dublin teams have wiped the floor with us at underage grades for 5 or 6 years. However the gap seems to have closed and we are expecting sucess at under 17 and under 20 in the next couple of years and if there is not serious questions have to be asked. There are example of 1 underage team becoming sucessful at senior and even losing teams. The examples are below 1 A recent example. The Kerry team that won 2014 senior final. Had allot of players from an under 21 that was hammerd by a Cork team in under 21 Munster championship. 2 The brillant 2 time All Ireland winning Galway team of the 90s was backboned by a minor Galway all ireland finalist team. 3 Meath All Ireland winning 1996 team. The greatest young team of the last 30 years. And one of the greatest ever young teams with Kerrys 1975 team. Had 7 under 21 from leinster winning team of the same year. 4 Clare hurling that lost under 21 Munster Final in the early 90s was managed by German loughnane and many of those players would play on 1995 and 1997 All Ireland winning teams 5 A very good comparison of different underage teams is limerick hurlers won 3 All Ireland under 21 titles in a row in early noughties. Huge expections were placed on those teams shoulders . It never translated to senior. A Waterford hurling lost minor final in the 90s with Paul Flynn and co. Those players backboned Waterfords Munster winning teams in the noughties. It's very hard to predict what players and teams at underage have sucess at senior level. Dont they get me wrong in that we have obtain more sucess at underage level. But that minor team which is the most sucessful team outside Dublin to come out of leinster in 15 years and with so many playing senior was a very good underage team.. Yes they were beaten by Dublin. That Dublin team was exceptional. And also they were like senior players in terms of physique. Those Mesth minors even at senior level are still quite small.and light. However when they reach 25 26 age bracket I think they will physically better able to deal with senior football. Meath are not as bad as many people want the. To be . They have one of the youngest teams in the country who have been knocking on the door to Division 1 for a couple of years have a great tradition and a strong management team. A sucessful Meath team in the next few years is not impossible. The years 2019 2020 2021 I can see Meath making an impact in the championship. Obtaining Division 1 status is essential. And staying in Division 1 is the key to sucess. Meath are not a million miles from getting into div1 finishing 3rd 3 times in four years losing out to score difference point difference and head to head . If Meath go up next year. When the players play div 1 in 2019 they will older and stronger for div 1 football . Players like McGill Harnan Rooney Sullivan McMahon etc would be 25 then. Furlong1949 (Meath) - Posts: 1067 - 14/07/2017 18:26:09 2016630 Link 0 |
Very good detailed post and i hate to pull you on one inaccuracy. McGeeney didn't play minor with Armagh in 1992. He was 31 in 2002. Barry O'Hagan and Marsden were the main men. I'm sure you remember Trevor Giles great pass to set up the winning goal in the final :)
Laois76 (Laois) - Posts: 1270 - 14/07/2017 21:02:18 2016692 Link 0 |
meath have some talented players from the current u16's,u17's and from the minor team 2 years ago. be interesting to see how these progress in a few years... ziggy32001 (Meath) - Posts: 8354 - 14/07/2017 21:56:27 2016704 Link 0 |
we are starting to beat dublin at underage. our u17's beat them easily in this years championship,our minors hammered them last year,our minors were 10 points up this year only to lose in added time. our bogey is still kildare at underage our u17's play them in newbridge tuesday in the u17 leinster semi. ziggy32001 (Meath) - Posts: 8354 - 14/07/2017 21:59:44 2016706 Link 0 |
Your 100% right. Ziggy. Two points 1 Kildare are our Bogey team full stop. We have a bit of a Kildare problem. Look at our championship record v every other team in leinster it's really good. I know we have a bad recent record v the Dubs. But overall our record v Dubs is the best in the country. Our record v teams outside the province is real good. Mayo Corks we arw their bogey team in the championship and good record v Kerry. Kildare, we underestimate. We think it's all Dublin. But it's Kildare that have emerged in laat 20 years or more as county we find hard to beat. In the last 50 years they have beaten us 8 times. After Dublin that is the best record any team has . Laois are next with 3 wins. We need to improve our record v kildare first before Dublin at senior. This year's game will be the first of a few meetings in the next few years in the championship between both of these young teams. Kildare do seem to have the basis of a quality team. As long they don't get another 15, 20 point hammering on Sunday. They look like a serious team. But at minor and under 21 year, Kildare have beaten us over and over in recent years. As well as Dublin. Dublin will continue to produce good underage teams. But so far in this decade they have produced brillant underage teams . If you look at record in the lower grades. The gap has closed and Meath are beaten Dublin consistently. Kildare might dip at underage. Which is natural. Meath have an opportunity and other counties eg louth8e Laois Westmeath have a chance in the next few years And looking at our record at under 14 15 etc. We should do well at the new minor and u20 level. But if we don't questions needed to be asked. In the last two years we had two good minor teams with allot of potential. However neither got to even a leinster final . We have got to get our work done at underage to turn into silverware in the next few years. If not serious questions have to be asked. One thing also . I cannot understand why more of the 90s team have not been used more at underage level. Barry Callaghan has had both minor and under 21 jobs. No real sucess other then 1 hammering v Dublin. But why is someone like Graham Geraghty not been involved at minor and under 21 level. He had managed at different levels. Was a Meath selector. In any other county someone Geraghty would be singled out and brought in. Look how Peter Cavanan Brian Dooher and Lohan are in charge of Tyrone under 21 team. And Darra O Se was Kerry under 21 manager. And Dessie Farrell was minor and under 21 manager. When Jim Galvin leaves Dessie Farrell is ready to take over. When Mickey Harte leaves, Lohan management team will probaly take over. Other counties have sucession plans in place. Jim Galvin and Jimmy McGuiness were under 21 managers first before senior . Why are people like Gerathy Seamis Kenny Anthony Moyes not been made our under 17 and and under 20 manager. Imagine if we were playing Dublin at under 20 next year. And Graham Geraghty was manager. Thats what we need to do. We need to do what other counties are doing. Furlong1949 (Meath) - Posts: 1067 - 15/07/2017 00:14:54 2016741 Link 0 |